Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Internment Without Trial.
- British internment without trial 30 speeches
The Government said it had raised internment with Britain on 12 occasions and viewed the system as politically counter-productive. It would support ending internment following a permanent ceasefire, though the Minister questioned when permanence could be established; no formal request was made during the recent ceasefire.
Michael O'Kennedy, Garrett Fitzgerald, Seán Treacy
- Irish internment under Special Powers Act 5 speeches
Blaney argued that Ireland’s own internment system under the Special Powers (Amendment) Act undermined its calls for Britain to end internment. Fitzgerald replied that Blaney’s criticism conflicted with his participation in a Government that operated the same system.
Seán Treacy, Neil T.C. Blaney, Garrett Fitzgerald
asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs if the Government will request the British Government to release all internees without trial in the event of an indefinite ceasefire in Northern Ireland.
8.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs the dates, if any, on which the Government formally requested the British Government to end internment without trial in Northern Ireland; and the response to each such request.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle I propose to take Questions Nos. 7 and 8 together.
Comment on this
The concern of the Irish Government about the system of detention as it operates in Northern Ireland has been made clear to the British Government.
Comment on this
The Government have done nothing in this area and there is no application this year in this regard.
Comment on this
Far from refusing to reply, I have a suspicion that my colleagues are becoming very impatient because of the amount of replying I am doing. Perhaps I should repeat the reply since I was shouted down from the other side.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister continued deliberately to speak while we were asking questions.
Comment on this
That is not a point of order. I ask the Deputy again to resume his seat and allow questions to continue in an orderly fashion. I shall not repeat that request.
Comment on this
As you are aware, a Cheann Comhairle, I did not begin to reply until you called the question and, the question having been called, I considered myself obliged to reply. Here is the reply to Questions Nos. 7 and 8.
Comment on this
The concern of the Irish Government about the system of detention as it operates in Northern Ireland has been made clear to the British Government. Since 14th March, 1973, various aspects of the question have been raised, on 12 separate occasions, at meetings between Irish and British Ministers.
With regard to the question of the release of all internees in the event of an indefinite ceasefire in Northern Ireland, the Government's view is that internment in the way it was introduced and the way it has operated was politically counter-productive. The continuation of that system of internment is making it more difficult to improve the political situation but the calculation of the rate at which the system can be dismantled involves security as well as political considerations and is, therefore, a matter primarily for those who have full information about the security as well as the political situation prevailing in Northern Ireland. It is, however, our hope and the British Government know it, that in the very near future there will be both a permanent ceasefire and an end to internment in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
In the event of a permanent ceasefire, would the Government request the British Government to put an immediate end to internment?
Comment on this
The phrases "permanent ceasefire" and "immediate end" are rather difficult to reconcile. A "permanent ceasefire" is something that one would have to see operating for a period before one could be sure of its permanency. I should not wish to give a precise yes to the Deputy's question although the general tenure of the Government's position would be along the lines the Deputy suggests.
Comment on this
The Northern Ireland Secretary of State, Mr. Rees, has given such a guarantee but our Government would seem to be somewhat less enthusiastic than he in that direction.
Comment on this
Let there be no misunderstanding regarding the word "immediate". An argument could arise as to what point it is clear that a ceasefire is permanent. That is the only distinction I would make but in principle the Government's position would be along the lines the Deputy has in mind.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say if any approach was made to the British Government during the recent ceasefire to request them to phase out internment?
Comment on this
There have been so many approaches that it is difficult to track down all of them. The matter of internment was raised with the British Government shortly before Christmas.
Comment on this
Was there a formal request to the British Government during the period of the ceasefire to end internment?
Comment on this
I do not think so. Our position has been so well-known for so long and on so many occasions that it was not considered necessary to reiterate it at that time.
Comment on this
This question which was tabled two weeks ago has been over-run by the events that have occurred in the meantime but in view of the developments at the time of the ceasefire, would the Minister not agree that it would have been appropriate to make a formal request at that time and that this, also, would have been productive politically?
Comment on this
Did I understand the Minister to say that this question has been raised on 12 occasions with the British?
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree that any of these approaches or that any new approaches would be more likely to bear fruit if it were seen that our Government were prepared to dismantle their pseudo-legal internment as it exists under the Special Powers (Amendment) Act? It is a totally false operation and it is a sham to ask others to end a system similar to something we are operating.