Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Nuclear Energy Board.
- Nuclear Energy Board expertise and staffing 8 speeches
The Minister listed the Board’s members and said it had met regularly and was recruiting expert staff. He was confident the Board and its staff could advise on nuclear safety, but said it had not yet provided advice.
Seán Browne, Peter Barry
- Need and timing of a nuclear station 8 speeches
The Minister said earlier electricity-demand forecasts had supported a nuclear station, but slower growth had led the ESB to defer its decision. He still favoured continued planning, while noting a station would take seven or eight years to produce electricity.
Seán Browne, Peter Barry, Florence Crowley, Tom J. Fitzpatrick
- Assessment of alternative energy sources 8 speeches
The Minister had asked the ESB to reassess wind, solar, tidal and other sources in light of the oil crisis. He considered the ESB the appropriate body to examine electricity-generation options, despite Haughey’s suggestion that a broader institution assess energy overall.
Charles J. Haughey, Peter Barry, Seán Treacy
- Location of a nuclear station 9 speeches
Brennan sought an undertaking that a nuclear station would be on the western seaboard; the Minister refused. The remaining exchanges were brief banter and procedural remarks as the Chair moved to the next question.
Joseph Brennan, Peter Barry, Seán Treacy, Seán Browne
asked the Minister for Transport and Power if he will state (a) the names of the members of the Nuclear Energy Board, (b) the date the board was established, (c) the number of meetings held by the board, (d) if the board has the necessary funds at its disposal to employ experts in the nuclear energy field, and (e) if any such experts have been employed to date.
Comment on this
The members of an Bórd Fuinnimh Nucleigh (The Nuclear Energy Board) are: Professor Charles T.G. Dillon (Chairman), Professor Cyril F. Delaney, Dr. Thomas Murray, Professor Palmer Newbould, Dr. John E. O'Connor, Professor Eva Maria Philbin, Dr. Thomas Walsh.
The board was established in December, 1973. The arrangements for meetings of the board and matters such as the recruitment of staff are the responsibility of the board itself. I understand, however, that the board has met regularly throughout the past year and that the question of recruitment of necessary staff is in hands. The board is in receipt of a grant-in-aid of £40,000 in the current financial year.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that there is a great deal of apprehension and concern, most of which is genuine but some of which is created by self-appointed experts, about the establishment of a nuclear power station? Is the Minister satisfied that we have the necessary experts and that the Nuclear Energy Board have available to them the necessary experts to advise him on the wisdom or otherwise of establishing a nuclear power station?
Comment on this
The list of members I have read out is, by any standards, a very impressive list of people. At the moment they are in the process of recruiting the necessary expert staff for themselves. I am satisfied that that board and the staff they will recruit will be capable of advising me on all matters related to nuclear safety.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that the ESB will have available to them the necessary experts to ensure the safety and all the other matters concerned with the establishment of a nuclear station?
Comment on this
Yes, I am quite satisfied. I should say that the purpose of setting up this board and of putting such highly qualified people on it was to ensure that the ESB, and the Government, had such necessary expert advise available to them.
Comment on this
The board have met regularly since they were established and they have been clearing their own minds on what line they would take and how they would organise the staff of the board. They have started recruiting staff and I understand that the first appointment will be announced shortly. This is the process of getting the board off the ground.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that the establishment of a nuclear power station or stations is essential here?
Comment on this
That is a very broad question and it would take me some time to answer it. I was satisfied that the rate of electricity growth demand prior to 1973 necessitated, in the long term, the establishment of a nuclear energy station. Since then, as the Deputy knows, things have changed.
Comment on this
That is frivolous. In the long term nuclear energy will probably, as far as we can see now and we are looking a long time ahead, be the major source of cheap electricity supply. That situation can change. The Deputy may have seen an announcement by the chief executive officer of the ESB recently to the effect that, because of the difference in demand, growth rate between 1973 and the current time they have put further back their decision on the establishment of a nuclear station. They still have not discarded it and I would not wish that they would do so. I would like them to go ahead planning for this station though without coming to a firm conclusion as to when it should be established.
Comment on this
Do I take it from this that the establishment of such a station is quite a long time away?
Comment on this
It would be quite some years anyway because the lead-in time for a nuclear station is seven years. Even if we made the decision now to establish such a station it would be seven or eight years before it would be producing electricity. That seven or eight years is now further back as a result of the ESB not seeing a pattern in the growth rate for electricity at present.
Comment on this
If the Deputy asks me that question in another ten years I will be able to give him a reply.
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell us anything in regard to the possible development of wind power, solar energy, sea power, or any other alternative source of energy?
Comment on this
I have asked the ESB to examine all these alternative sources which would not have been economic up to the time of the oil crisis. I have asked them to reexamine any of the schemes that were put before them to see if they are now economic or if they could be used now.
Comment on this
In entrusting this examination to the ESB is the Minister satisfied that the ESB is the appropriate body seeing that they are primarily electricity producers?
Comment on this
These are methods of producing electricity and they have the necessary expertise to deal with these matters. I have said before that, while there has been a lot of criticism about the ESB, that body has been fairly successful in forecasting the demand and planning to meet the demands for the supply of electricity over 50 years.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister does not take it that I am criticising the ESB. In fact I am frequently on record as commending the ESB. I am wondering if some broader type of institution should not be looking at the overall energy situation and alternative sources of energy.
Comment on this
What we are talking about is the production of electricity principally from wind generation, or from tidal waves, or smaller hydro schemes, or space heating and so on. It would be properly the function of the ESB to investigate it. I think they are the right body.
Comment on this
Can the Minister now give us an undertaking that the nuclear energy station will be on the western seaboard?
Comment on this
Would it not be better to establish something new rather than dragging up something that is already established?