We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Textile and Footwear Dumping.

Alleged Dumping of Textiles and Footwear

Summary

The Minister said the dumping inquiry into textiles, clothing and footwear from low-cost countries would take time, noting that dumping can be difficult to prove. Deputies criticised the delay and cited cheap shirts arriving in containers; the Minister invited evidence for the commission and agreed to ask Customs to verify the claims.

asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce if, arising out of proposed discussions with EEC representatives, he will indicate whether any arrangements have been made or will shortly be made to deal with dumping affecting the textile trade and especially the shirt manufacturing factories in County Donegal.

49.

Comment on this
Padraig Faulkner Mr. Faulkner, Mr. Farrell and Mr. Leonard Fianna Fáil

asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce when a report is expected from An Coimisiún Dumpála concerning the inquiry into allegation of the dumping of textiles, clothing, and footwear from Far Eastern countries and from Eastern European countries.

Comment on this

With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 48 and 49 together.

An Coimisiún Dumpála announced on 10th January that they had initiated an investigation into the alleged dumping of footwear, textiles and clothing products including shirts originating in certain low-cost countries and invited representations from interested parties.

In view of the scope of these investigations, I am informed that some time may elapse before the report of An Coimisiún Dumpála can be presented. I am assured, however, that the matter will be brought to a conclusion as soon as possible.

Comment on this

Would the Minister agree that An Coimisiún Dumpála should have begun their investigations some months ago?

Comment on this

The matter is not as simple as that. We were faced with the real alternative that if An Coimisiún Dumpála find there is no dumping, the final position is worse than when we started. In invoking this mechanism one takes a very real risk because the Deputy will be aware that though it is very unsatisfactory, dumping in its formal sense is very difficult to prove, especially in the case of goods coming from extremely low-cost areas. The decision to invoke the mechanism of An Coimisiún Dumpála is not automatic.

Comment on this

Would the Minister agree that the decision has been made to investigate allegations of dumping? Would he not agree that this matter was raised on numerous occasions from this side of the House over a considerable number of months? If it is found that dumping has been taking place, would he not agree that it would equally have been found that dumping was taking place if the investigation had been carried out some months ago and the jobs of very many people would have been saved in the meantime?

Comment on this

That is a hypothetical question with words like "a considerable number of months" and "very many people". It is a question with such lack of precision and so hypothetical that it does not call for an answer.

Comment on this

Might I further ask the Minister if he will agree that this matter was raised on numerous occasions here and that it was clearly shown that there was a grave danger that dumping was taking place? Why has this decision only been taken now, a decision that should have been taken months ago and so would have saved the employment of many workers in these industries?

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that at Alexandra Quay very many containers of cheap shirts are landed at five shillings per shirt? It should not take An Coimisiúin Dumpála or the Minister very long to find that out. While the Minister has been fiddling around with this problem is he aware that the country is being flooded with this type of textile goods? Will he go down himself and do what I did? I found that this was the position—container after container landing shirts at five shillings each.

Comment on this

I am in the difficulty that when Deputies ask questions that are argumentative and that contain imprecision such as "very many containers" and "this type of textile goods" in a totally undefined way, a satisfactory answer is difficult.

Comment on this

It is very definite. Two allegations.

Comment on this

If the Deputy has evidence that can prove something quickly he should have given it to me in the past. I am happy to get it now and I will see that it is passed to the commission instantly. The Deputy must recognise that we are not in circumstances where unilateral actions in these areas are helpful or productive of anything except chaos and mess and trouble.

Comment on this

I have given the Minister the information I have. Will the Minister ask the customs section of the Department of Finance who have people employed at Alexandra Quay and who are dealing with the matters I have discussed about this or will he ask the Minister for Finance to inquire whether what I say is true or false?

Comment on this

I will be perfectly happy to do that.

Comment on this