Comprehensive youth policy
The Minister said a comprehensive youth policy was under preparation, would address youth services alongside related education and recreation provision, and was not delayed by funding. He would not give a publication date or disclose planned funding; he described the President’s Award as potentially suitable for a pilot scheme and denied that youth organisations were totally dissatisfied.
asked the Minister for Education when he proposes to announce and publish a Government policy for youth.
21.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education if he will announce a national youth policy immediately.
22.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education when he expects to publish a comprehensive policy on youth development.
23.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education if he will give details of his reported £1 million youth plan.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 20, 21, 22, 23 and 24 together.
The comprehensive study of the entire youth service which I undertook is at a very advanced stage at present. However, youth policy, as the Deputies will appreciate, cannot be determined in isolation but must be seen as part of a wider educational context including adult education, sports and recreational development.
Decisions will be taken within a wider context, but I feel that until the youth policy document is available for discussion it would be inappropriate to comment further on the policy at this stage. A date has not yet been fixed for the publication of the document but I can assure the Deputies that I am as anxious as they are to have it published at the earliest possible date.
Comment on this
Is it true that over 12 months ago every youth organisation in the country submitted their views on what they thought would be the Parliamentary Secretary's views on a comprehensive youth policy and, so far, no communication at all has been sent to any youth organisation regarding the delay in producing this comprehensive scheme?
Comment on this
In view of the absence of a comprehensive youth policy, would the Parliamentary Secretary consider appointing regional development youth officers who will be responsible for organising and promoting youth leadership?
Comment on this
I hope that the youth policy will be available in the near future and will outline the measures we hope to take in both the national and the regional context.
Comment on this
This is a very important matter. Could the Parliamentary Secretary give us any idea of what the "near future" means? Youth development is in complete disarray and the Parliamentary Secretary is aware that that is so. Would the Parliamentary Secretary give us an approximate time as to when he hopes to publish this comprehensive youth policy?
Comment on this
I will not give the Deputy an approximate time because I do not wish to make any promise over which I might not be able to stand. However, I would point out that this is the first attempt by any Government at formulating a comprehensive policy in this area.
Comment on this
That is why the Parliamentary Secretary has been interrupted so many times in the past two years.
Comment on this
What Deputy O'Kennedy has just stated is not correct. However, I shall not go into that. This is not an easy area in which to formulate a policy. There is a great diversity of organisations and needs which have to be taken into account. The subject itself presents obvious problems in finding concepts and realistic targets for a policy and one must have such identifiable targets, I believe, for a policy reassessment if one is not to waste public money. One basic decision I have taken is that youth services should not be isolated either conceptually or administratively from analogous services for other age groups, such as sport and adult education. It immediately follows from this that we also have to have some idea of future plans in such analogous areas as well if we are to see how youth services fit in. I am glad to say that I have a "sport for all" policy now at an advanced stage of preparation.
The suggestion has been made that the non-publication of the comprehensive policy is holding up progress. This may be somewhat overstated. We already operate a flexible grant-in-aid scheme for national and voluntary organisations to one or other of which nearly every youth club in the country is affiliated. There is nothing stopping groups within those organisations coming up with new schemes at this minute so long as they are within the budget of their own national organisation. Indeed, I have been successful in getting reasonably improved resources for this grant-in-aid scheme this year and also in introducing a new flexibility in the form of a new subhead for aid. I have also made it clear that this scheme will continue and that the initiative of voluntary organisations will remain. However, a problem does arise where individual local groups look for special aids outside the context of this grant-in-aid scheme, or where structures are sought to be set up which would create precedents elsewhere. To be fair to everybody, one needs a comprehensive policy in that situation and that is what I am engaged upon.
Comment on this
In connection with this policy and matters the Parliamentary Secretary described as analogous, may I ask him whether or not he has killed the President Award scheme which had been initiated before he took office?
Comment on this
Could the Parliamentary Secretary say what is the position with regard to that scheme, a scheme which had already commenced?
Comment on this
I do not think it is correct to say it had already commenced before I took office. I hope to have structures within which such a scheme will fit, perhaps on a pilot basis initially, but I would prefer not to go into it in detail at this stage.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary accept that I, as Parliamentary Secretary, had given a direction before I left office that this scheme should be proceeded with?
Comment on this
Then the Parliamentary Secretary must not have read the direction. That is the position obviously.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary accept that various youth organisations, the National Youth Council and the National Federation of Youth Clubs, and all organisations concerned with youth are gravely concerned and have expressed consistent dissatisfaction with the Parliamentary Secretary's failure to promote and publish his youth policy? Does he accept that? Does he accept that they speak on behalf of the youth and they have expressed total dissatisfaction and frustration because of the Parliamentary Secretary's failure to produce a policy.
Comment on this
I will accept that they have expresssed concern but they have not at all expressed total dissatisfaction.
Comment on this
It is a matter of interpretation. We can only interpret their views. It appears that the Parliamentary Secretary does not share the dissatisfaction which the rest of us apprehend from the youth organisations. That is regrettable. Has the Parliamentary Secretary any justification for associating the youth programme with other areas, such as the adult education programme and the recreation programme and, in particular, may we take it now that, if the Parliamentary Secretary fails to take any step in the area of recreation, which he has, in fact, failed to do, that his justification for not taking any further steps towards implementing a youth policy now that he has informed us that all three areas——
Comment on this
I do not agree progress has not been made. Very significant progress has been made in increasing the level of the grant-in-aid last year to youth organisations and in obtaining this year in very difficult economic circumstances considerably improved aid for the same scheme in the 1975 Estimates. When the policies become available it will be evident, I think, and I hope the policy will be available in the not too distant future, that they are in many ways interdependent. The Deputy will agree, I am sure, that it is undesirable that we should have a sort of youth ghetto apart from those provisions in other areas. He will also agree that in many areas the input into youth policy is an educational one given in an informal setting during leisure time and in that way it is analogous to both adult education and, indeed, to the educational aspect of sport promotion. I am anxious to try to see these proposals accomplished to the full. I really merely wish to see a rough outline of where the other schemes are going so that we can go ahead on a more precise and definite basis.
Comment on this
Who is advising the Parliamentary Secretary in the preparation of this comprehensive scheme?
Comment on this
Numerous people, including the national youth organisations which have been most helpful in coming forward with advice. I have been meeting them repeatedly up to very recently and submissions were received from one of the organisations as recently as early in January.
Comment on this
We cannot debate this matter here at this stage. The Chair has been most generous. I will take one final supplementary from Deputy Haughey.
Comment on this
My question is in three parts. First of all, would the Parliamentary Secretary confirm because there seems to be some doubt about it, that he is still committed to the production of a comprehensive youth policy at the earliest possible moment; secondly, would he indicate whether the provision of funds is in any way related to the delay and, if that is so, would he come clean with the House and the people, who are interested in this matter, and let us know the exact situation; thirdly, would he indicate whether the publication in one of the newspapers recently, which purported to be the structure of the comprehensive youth policy he is producing, was, in fact, in any way valid or had any relation to what he is proposing?
Comment on this
The answer to the first part of the question is "Yes". The answer to the second part is "No". The answer to the third part is that the report in question bears a close resemblance to a document I prepared for expressly confidential discussion in relation to youth policy. I did not agree to the release of the document to a newspaper. Obviously meaningful discussions can take place only on the basis of a document actually agreed by the Government. I hope that such a document will be ready for publication reasonably soon.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary is sure finance is not holding up this matter, has he some idea of the amount involved and whether anything is provided in the Estimates this year?
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary has no idea. The Parliamentary Secretary said that even if he had an idea he would not disclose it. What is the amount involved?