Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Feakle Peace Meeting.
- Cost of Feakle security operation 13 speeches
The Minister refused to disclose deployment details that could quantify the operation’s cost. Loughnane challenged its value and objected to disrupting a peace meeting, while Cooney defended the Garda’s security duties and the Chair confined the question to cost.
William Loughnane, Patrick Mark Cooney, Seán Treacy
- Feakle arrests and government position 18 speeches
Blaney questioned how the Government could praise the meeting while people who attended were arrested. Cooney said the Government’s security policy was unchanged and that those sought were IRA members wanted for serious crimes; Loughnane challenged this account by asking about Bishop Butler, and Blaney returned to the apparent inconsistency.
Neil T.C. Blaney, Seán Treacy, Patrick Mark Cooney, William Loughnane
asked the Minister for Justice the cost to the State of the raid by the Special Detective Unit and other members of the forces during the course of the Feakle peace meeting.
Comment on this
It would be contrary to well-established and, in my opinion, fully justified practice for me to give information which might be used to quantify the deployment of Garda personnel and other resources in the carrying out of a security operation.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that this raid was abortive? Is it any wonder, then, that the increase in the cost of security for one year was £24 million or is the Minister aware of what the meeting was about?
Comment on this
That would seem to be a separate matter. The question refers only to the cost to the State in respect of the matter referred to.
Comment on this
May I say in reply to the implications of the Deputy's statement that no apology is made on behalf of the Garda for carrying out their duty at any time they consider fit in order to ensure the security of the State. To suggest that money spent on security is money wasted ill-becomes the Deputy.
Comment on this
The Deputy is bringing in an irrelevant matter. The question appertains to cost only.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say whether the Government have changed their minds regarding their favourable comment on the usefulness of this meeting?
Comment on this
I shall not attempt to broaden the scope of the question but I should like to know whether, if the Government have not changed their minds, how they can justify having arrested two of those who took part in those talks?
Comment on this
All I can say to the Deputy is that this Government have not changed their minds in regard to security or the protection of the institutions of this State. As long as people break the law they will be hunted out and arrested.
Comment on this
Is it considered to be in the interest of the security of the State to arrest a Protestant clergyman? These honourable men were working in the interest of peace.
Comment on this
The Deputy is well aware that the people who were sought on that occasion were not Protestant clergymen but were members of the IRA who were wanted for serious crime. Does the Deputy object to those men being sought out?
Comment on this
I was attempting to be in order without interrupting either the Minister or the Chair but perhaps I was not heard. Arising from the last supplementary reply——
Comment on this
This is not in order. The Chair will deal only with the subject matter of questions before the House.
Comment on this
Neither the Chair nor anybody else could be aware as to whether I was in order since I have not asked the question. My question arises from the Minister's supplementary reply that the raid in Feakle was carried out in connection with the security of the State——
Comment on this
——and I want to ask him why, then, the talks were praised by the Government as a worthwhile effort?
Comment on this
I regret that there should be criticism in this House by any Deputy, no matter what might be his past, of the Garda for carryout their duty.