Extension of brucellosis-free area
Murphy said no decision had been made on when to extend the brucellosis-free area. Callanan argued that poor implementation in existing areas made extension questionable, but the Chair ruled that operational complaints were outside the question; Murphy invited complaints to be submitted to the Department.
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries when the brucellosis-free area will be extended.
Comment on this
Is the Parliamentary Secretary aware that in the areas where it is compulsory at present it is being held up because the full herds have gone down and the Department are still——
Comment on this
I am asking if there is any use in extending the scheme when it is being badly handled where it has been in operation. I can prove that in my own county.
Comment on this
That is not a point of order—and the Deputy should know that—at Question Time. The question on the Order Paper is concerned with when the brucellosis-free area will be extended.
Comment on this
Exactly. He is referring to the extension of the brucellosis-free area, and surely the scheme must be operated within the boundaries——
Comment on this
No. If the Deputy wishes to pursue that line it would mean we could have argument here at Question Time instead of answers and questions.
Comment on this
What I am asking for a ruling on is that I think it unfair to say in relation to a voluntary scheme and the extension of the area, that if a Deputy wants to solicit information relating to the present scheme——
Comment on this
On a point of order, if the Chair would allow me—I do not cause a lot of trouble in the House —the relevance of my question was this: Deputy MacSharry's question related to the extension of the scheme and I was asking about the wisdom of extending it, seeing that a bad job was being made of it.
Comment on this
The question relates to when the brucellosis-free area will be extended and the answer is that no decision has been taken. How the scheme operates does not arise from this question, and if there are any complaints about the operation of the scheme and the Deputy submits them to the Department they will be examined.