Television Signal Tests at Moycullen
Asked about claimed signals at Pollnaclogha, the Minister said no test results had reached his Department. Cable operators, not the Department, would conduct and monitor extended tests because reception depends on the mast’s location and cost.
asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs if he is aware that a cable television company are of the opinion that a signal can be got from UTV, BBC 1 and BBC 2 at 900 feet at Pollnaclogha, Moycullen, County Galway; and if he will arrange to have tests carried out at this location to confirm the signal.
Comment on this
I have received no information about the results of any tests for signals taken at Pollnaclogha, Moycullen, County Galway. If such information is received it will be carefully examined by my Department.
Comment on this
On receipt of such information would it be the practice of the Department to have tests carried out such as those suggested in the question?
Comment on this
The Department's information, based on knowledge about distance from BBC and UTV transmitters, is that signals which would provide acceptable reception on the cable system are not available off air in Galway city. In order to provide acceptable reception the signals would need to be available on a continuous basis and tests would need to be undertaken during a fairly long period to establish the quality and regularity of such signals.
Comment on this
Will the tests be carried out by the Department as distinct from potential operators of cable television?
Comment on this
It is regarded as inadvisable for the Department to arrange tests of signals quality as suggested. The only people who can usefully make such tests are cable operators who would have to have regard to the type and location of mast it would be economic to provide in relation to the estimated capital and running costs of a cable system in that area. The quality of reception on a cable system depends not only on the signals available off air but also on the type of mast provided and its proposed location. Accordingly, there would be no point in the Department carrying out tests in the absence of evidence of tests carried out by cable operators interested in providing the scheme, together with particulars of the type and location of mast proposed. Moreover it would be undesirable for the Department to do anything which would involve taking responsibility for the quality of signals in the case of multi-channel cable television systems. The signals at best are of the fringe type and are below what would be regarded as acceptable by normal engineering standards.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister if the Department were to receive such information, would they carry out their own tests. From his answer I am not quite clear if the answer is "yes" or "no".