We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Cattle Trade.

Passing intervention benefits to producers

Summary

Gibbons sought a system to determine cattle eligibility at sale points and pay intervention benefits directly to producers, alleging unfair access and sharp practices at some factories. Clinton said intervention and slaughter-premium payments required specific evidence, and that tracing ownership was difficult when cattle passed through dealers; the exchange became heated over prices and responsibility.

asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries the arrangements he has made to ensure that the full benefit of the new intervention price is passed on to the producer.

Comment on this

I would refer the Deputy to the reply which I gave on 30th January to a similar question by Deputy Hugh Gibbons.

As the Deputy is aware, I am at present arranging for a review of the operation here of the EEC beef intervention and slaughter premium arrangements.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not agree that a more equitable system for the payment of intervention-type cattle and also for cattle which qualify for the slaughter premium would be a method whereby their status would be determined at sale points and payment made by the intervention agency against sale documents?

Comment on this

The Deputy probably appreciates that we would all be extremely anxious to get a fair distribution of the profits at the various points. None of the member states is satisfied with the present arrangement whereby the profit is at the point of slaughter and does not go back to the producer. So far nobody has put forward a way of improving the situation. There is particular difficulty in our case because our set-up in this respect is of a type not to be found anywhere on the Continent, that is, that cattle going through a mart may either be going direct for export as live cattle or they may go into the processing factories where they qualify for any of a number of interventions or, not so qualifying, attract the slaughter premium. There are many aspects to this problem.

If we were to reach a point where we could say that the processing factories can take only X pence per lb. profit for the service they are providing, there would be the situation that while one factory might be able to put almost a 100 per cent of their intake into intervention, another, because of lack of freezing facilities might not be able to put any into intervention. The problem is very difficult and that is why we have undertaken to set up an expert group so that they may find a way around this.

Comment on this

Would the Minister undertake to examine my suggestion? Also, would he not agree that the set-up of certain meat factories during the past 12 months lent itself to a great deal of sharp practice and to the building up of very large fortunes by some individuals at the expense of the producers? I ask the Minister to take whatever drastic steps are necessary to ensure that this situation cannot continue.

Comment on this

The Deputy is aware that we, as the intervention agency, must pay intervention prices to the people who give us frozen meat of a certain quality. In relation to the other premium which is a slaughter premium, we must have evidence of slaughter.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister is aware that in certain meat factories and, indeed, in certain allegedly cooperative meat factories, there is a clique of people who have access for practically any numbers they wish while other shareholders of the same factory have no access? Obviously, this is unjust.

Comment on this

Would Deputy Crinion like to comment on the clique of people who have access to the factories?

Comment on this

I suggest that the Minister confine himself to his own Department.

Comment on this

Would it not be a simple matter for the Minister as the buying agent to have officers of his Department ensure that farmers are paid the intervention price less the handling charge, for cattle that are certified for intervention? This has not being happening.

Comment on this

It could have gone through two dealers before it arrived in the factory. It would be difficult to ascertain when the producer was the owner.

Comment on this

This is not contentious but it is an important matter. Could the status of the cattle not be determined at sale points, as has been done in Great Britain for decades under the deficiency payments system?

Comment on this

As the Deputy knows, the big problem was with regard to the store that was being sold at 6 cwt. That was the one hardest hit and it was the area we wanted to get the money to. How does one start to declare status at that point? I can assure Deputies opposite I wanted to do something with regard to the matters about which they are concerned.

Comment on this

If the person who was selling the bigger cattle got the full price that would have gone down along the line.

Comment on this

How can the Deputy seriously say that?

Comment on this

I can because it is true.

Comment on this

I have seen producers like Deputy Crinion who said for months that prices would go lower and who told the people to hold on not to buy. What happened was that prices went through the floor.

Comment on this

The failure was the Minister's.

Comment on this

Deputy Crinion made tons of money on this.

Comment on this

If the Minister had devalued the £——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Question No. 10.

10.

Comment on this