Price support for store cattle
Clinton said the Brussels package improved support for beef and cattle, with benefits expected to reach store cattle as abnormal market conditions eased. Gibbons argued a calf birth premium would better stimulate herd growth than the clean-cattle premium; Clinton said the Italian arrangement involved foregoing other supports and was unsuitable for Ireland.
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if, in view of the fact that the recent Brussels package has failed to ensure a price support mechanism for store cattle producers, he will indicate the steps he proposes to take to correct this situation.
Comment on this
The EEC arrangements for price support are concerned primarily with marketing of the finished products and the recent Brussels package provided very substantial improvements for beef and cattle. The benefits of these can be expected to extend to all categories of cattle, including stores, now that the abnormal situation of last year, due primarily to earlier excessive third-country beef imports into the Community, has been overcome.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree that the deal got by the Italian Government for their farmers, in so far as they renounced the clean cattle premium in preference to a birth premium on calves of £25 payable in two stages, would be more suitable for our cattle industry than the clean cattle premium?
Comment on this
I do not think that would be generally accepted here because, as the Deputy knows, frequently the calf producers and those who finish the cattle are not the same people. There would be serious disagreement if we were to forego intervention and the slaughter premiums——
Comment on this
They are not intervening and they said that at the Council meeting. They do not have to because they import 50 per cent——
Comment on this
We export 85 per cent of our cattle. Is the Minister aware that what the Italians are getting is a direct stimulus for the production of calves? Since it is our purpose to increase the size of our herd, is it not perfectly clear that it would be better for us to exchange the clean cattle premiums which goes to beef producers for one that goes to the calf producers?
Comment on this
We have the beef incentive scheme that the Italians have not got. Is the Deputy saying we should forego that scheme and every other benefit to get £25 for calves?
Comment on this
I am not saying we should forego the beef incentive scheme. I am talking about the clean cattle premium, the 30 units of account premium. If the Minister had exchanged that for the calf premium he would be doing a far better job.