Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Architectural Heritage Year.
- Architectural heritage projects and employment 25 speeches
The Minister listed two European pilot projects and 29 other schemes, but said their varied funding and use of voluntary labour made employment estimates impossible. Faulkner pressed for labour-intensive restoration to support construction jobs; the Minister defended rehabilitation work, while their exchanges over the answer drew procedural interventions.
Padraig Faulkner, James Tully, Seán Treacy, George Colley, Raymond MacSharry
- Amenity grants for restoration 6 speeches
Power said withdrawing amenity grants had set back counties restoring old public buildings. Tully disputed their use in Kildare, and Power criticized the Minister’s response.
Patrick Power, Seán Treacy, James Tully
- Heritage restoration and construction unemployment 18 speeches
Faulkner cited Denmark’s use of Architectural Heritage Year to address unemployment and asked Ireland to do likewise; Tully replied that Danish unemployment had risen and pointed to restoration work already underway. The exchange included claims about construction-sector unemployment and ended with Power seeking permission to raise the Minister’s reply and comments about Kildare on the Adjournment.
Padraig Faulkner, Seán Treacy, James Tully, George Colley, Patrick Power
- Greencastle fishing fleet compensation 8 speeches
Blaney gave notice of his intention to raise the Greencastle fleet’s continued inactivity after an attack and the need for assessment and compensation to return it to the water.
Neil T.C. Blaney, Seán Treacy
asked the Minister for Local Government the projects that are being proposed in connection with Architectural Heritage Year; and the estimated employment content thereof.
Comment on this
Two Irish projects for European Architectural Heritage Year have been accepted for the European programme of pilot projects. These involve redevelopment at St. John's Square, Limerick, and open space and amenity development at Holycross Village, County Tipperary. Twenty-nine other schemes are being undertaken by local authorities, the Office of Public Works, and voluntary organisations. Because of the number of bodies, both public and private, involved in projects, the reliance in some cases on voluntary labour, and the variety of schemes being carried out it is not possible to estimate the total employment content.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that his Department should promote as many projects as possible during European Architectural Heritage Year involving work on buildings and houses so as to alleviate the problem of unemployment in the building and construction industry?
Comment on this
Deputy Faulkner should be aware that the building of houses could not be included in European Architectural Heritage Year projects. However, we are doing everything we possibly can to have old houses made useful again for habitation.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that the rehabilitation of old buildings, their adaptation to new uses, and the upgrading of areas that have declined, are labour-intensive operations which, in relation to the expenditure involved, make greater demands on available building and craft skills than do large-scale operations? Therefore, would the Minister see to it that in so far as the Department can become involved——
Comment on this
I will give a very short answer. I am glad to see that Fianna Fáil have been converted to the idea that we should not pull down every old building in the country when we have finished using it.
Comment on this
Deputy Faulkner has only to look around him in this city and in his own town of Drogheda to see that it is in operation.
Comment on this
At Question Time we are entitled, I hope, to a reasonable reply to a reasonable question.
Comment on this
I want to protest at this protection of the Minister who is refusing to answer the question. If a Minister is giving the reply, the business proceeds normally. If he is not, and he is being obstructive like the Minister for Local Government, I want to protest, Sir, at your calling the next question. The very least that could be done is to allow the Minister to be questioned and shown up if he is incapable of answering the question.
Comment on this
Deputies know that the Chair has no control over Ministers' replies and indeed seems to have little control over Deputies' supplementary questions also.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree that counties that were using the amenity grants for work of this nature, to restore old buildings, and particularly public buildings for further use, have received a very severe setback in their efforts because of the withdrawal of amenity grants this year?
Comment on this
I should like to state that this question found its way into a booklet this year. It is no thanks to the Minister that it is in such a condition.
Comment on this
Might I ask one more reasonable and sensible question? Is the Minister aware that it is the declared intention of the Danish Government to harness the European Architectural Heritage Year campaign to alleviate the country's unemployment? Would he agree that our Government could equally emulate the decision of the Danish Government?
Comment on this
Yes, and the number unemployed in Denmark has increased by 300 per cent. Perhaps the Deputy is aware of that also.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that the biggest number unemployed in this country is in the building industry?
Comment on this
I have asked very reasonable and pertinent questions. When one takes into consideration particularly that there were 2,355 more people unemployed in the building industry in January, 1975 than there were in January, 1974, surely I am entitled to get a reasonable answer to a reasonable question?
Comment on this
Deputy Faulkner asked was I aware that the repair of old buildings was a labour-intensive operation. Of course, everybody is aware of that; it has not to be asked here in this House. Deputy Faulkner is also aware that since I took over as Minister I have had more old buildings taken over, repaired and made suitable for use by families than was ever done before in this country. Why try to make a joke of it by trying to pretend it is something he thought of just a few minutes ago?
Comment on this
On a point of order, in view of the unsatisfactory nature of the Minister's reply to this question and in view of the aspersions he found it fit to cast on Kildare County Council, I should like the Chair's permission to raise the matter on the Adjournment.
Comment on this
Deputy Blaney, I have called the next question repeatedly. I am now insisting on proceeding with that question and will, proceed with it.
Comment on this
What I want to do is to give notice to the Chair, with his permission, that in view of the fact that the Greencastle fleet has been entirely tied up since the attack made on it some time ago, might I be allowed raise the matter of early examination, assessment and compensation so that this fleet might be got back in the water?