We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Teacher Ban Removal.

asked the Minister for Education if he will remove the ban on teachers over 65 years who had participated in the capitation scheme and are thus deprived of pensions.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Minister for Foreign Affairs (Dr. FitzGerald) (for the Minister for Education) Fine Gael

In order to ensure that posts will be available for the 1,100 newly-trained teachers who will be coming out of the colleges of education at the end of the current academic year, the special concession whereby teachers have, on certain conditions, been retained in the teaching service beyond the normal retiring date will not operate in the forthcoming school year. It is not possible to make an exception in favour of one particular category of such teachers. A claim for pension credit for service in capitation schools is at present before the Teachers' Conciliation Council.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that members of religious orders, nuns in particular—I have been asked to raise this matter on their behalf— some of whom have been working in schools for 30 years and 45 years, are now asked to retire this year, that they are not entitled to any pension and would have no function in the school and will not qualify for an old age pension for a two-year period? Does the Minister not consider that this is placing a great burden on a section of the community who have given very great service in the education and other fields to the Irish community?

Comment on this

Yes. I appreciate the difficulties the Deputy raised and as I mentioned at the end of my reply a claim for pension credit for service in these capitation schools is at present before the Teachers' Conciliation Council. It is not possible, however, to select a particular category for special treatment because there are other groups for whom claims might also be made of hardship in these circumstances and the balance of human advantage seems to lie with taking this step of not continuing this practice, which is an exceptional practice, in operation in the current year so as to maximise the number of new teachers who will gain employment rather than create a situation where they could not and might have to seek employment elsewhere in the current year.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister will accept that I would agree that to make places for those coming out of training colleges is praiseworthy but what I am raising here is the plight in which those teachers have been placed who do not qualify for a pension because of the capitation system of payment. Nuns and brothers are particularly badly hit, people whose salaries in the past have gone back into the building of new schools and meeting debts on schools. They are in a particular category having made special sacrifices more than any other section of the community and they are now being left as a severe financial imposition on their orders. In one religious house of nuns there is a drop in income of £10,000.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is making a speech, not asking a question.

Comment on this

I appreciate the very real difficulty imposed. There is a claim at conciliation level that is under consideration and a decision is due shortly. However, I am not in a position to anticipate that decision.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to ensure that a sympathetic and favourable decision will be made as soon as possible.

Comment on this

I will convey the Deputy's views on this matter.

Comment on this

I raised a similar question with the Minister nearly a year ago and I was then told the matter was at conciliation level and that a decision was expected. Is the Minister in a position to say a decision will be made in the next month?

Comment on this

It is intended to convene a further meeting of the conciliation council before the end of the month to discuss this matter and other claims with regard to teachers' pensions. Immediate action is taking place on the matter.

Comment on this

Can the Minister state if there is some hope for the nuns and brothers who have been thrown out without any pension from the State?

Comment on this

I do not think the words "thrown out" are appropriate to the situation——

Comment on this

I am merely expressing the feeling that exists about this matter.

Comment on this

I can understand that. An extension of service which took place previously is not being maintained in the coming year. It is the abandonment of an exceptional arrangement because of a greater need elsewhere. Having said that, I cannot accept the Deputy's words. I accept the real character of the problem and I will convey the Deputy's views.

Comment on this

The Minister has some influence there, also.

Comment on this