Carrickatleave transport to Meentinadea
The Department said no children in Carrickatleave qualified under the distance rules, while Brennan maintained that children faced a long, bleak walk and challenged the rules’ application and flexibility. The Minister defended consistent eligibility rules and said ineligible children could travel as fare-paying passengers if seats were available.
asked the Minister for Education if he will reconsider his decision not to provide transport for children from the townland of Carrickatleave to Meentinadea national school, County Donegal.
Comment on this
In order to warrant the provision of a transport service to a national school from a particular locality, the number of children eligible for free transport in that locality must be at least ten. In a recent survey of the Carrickatleave area no child was found to be eligible. Eligible children are those between four and ten years of age who have a distance of at least two miles to travel to the nearest suitable school while for children over ten years of age the minimum distance is three miles. Accordingly, the provision of a transport service to cater for this locality is not warranted under the terms of the scheme.
Comment on this
We are becoming tired of this stock reply. Is the Parliamentary Secretary prepared to admit that these rules are capable of being bent, that they have been bent in many cases particularly in relation to Protestant schools? Has he any knowledge of what is involved in the request I have made on behalf of the 12 children who must walk along a bleak lonely mountain road for a distance of more than two miles and three of whom are beginning school? If transport is not provided they will not be able to go to school. Other children who live closer to the school can avail of free transport. Is it not time that this whole question of measuring miles was changed——
Comment on this
——and that the rule which we fixed at the beginning and which is flexible and subject to the discretion of the Minister be changed so as to allow transport for all children?
Comment on this
Practically all the children in this case are less than two miles from the nearest school.
Comment on this
Various exceptional circumstances might be put forward in respect of every school in Ireland but to operate a scheme in a proper manner one must abide by basic rules.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary has not answered my question as to whether he would admit that the rule has been bent in many instances, that it is subject to the discretion of the Minister. Surely a case can be made for including children who must walk more than two miles on a bare mountain road.