We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Single Women's Allowance.

Gender Differences in Social Welfare

Summary

Andrews asked which social welfare entitlements treated women differently and when the anomalies would be removed. The Minister described progress on recommendations from the Commission on the Status of Women and agreed to send Andrews details of those implemented, partly implemented, under examination, or not pursued.

asked the Minister for Social Welfare if he will indicate the categories of women social welfare recipients who do not have the same scale of entitlements as men; and the action, if any, he intends to take to deal with the problem as a matter of urgency.

Comment on this

Some of the wide range of social security schemes administered by my Department apply only to women, others extend to men and women on an equal basis and in other instances men and women are treated differently.

In the case of disability benefit, invalidity pension, unemployment benefit and unemployment assistance a single man or a widower may be paid a housekeeper's allowance if he has a dependent child and is wholly or mainly maintaining a woman to take care of the child. This allowance is not yet payable to single women or widows.

A married woman claimant who is being wholly or mainly maintained by her husband is paid unemployment benefit, disability benefit and invalidity pension at a rate lower than that payable to a single man or a single woman. The duration of unemployment benefit for such a married woman is limited to 156 days as compared to the 312 days duration applying to single women and men between 18 and 65 years of age.

In the case of unemployment assistance, there are qualifying conditions applying to women applicants which do not apply to men. A single woman or a widow must either have a dependant or 52 employment contributions in the four contribution years preceding that in which unemployment assistance is claimed. A married woman applicant must not be dependent on her husband and must have at least one dependant.

I am conscious of the need to eliminate all instances of what might be regarded as discrimination against women in my Department's schemes. Many of the improvements in that regard recommended by the Commission on the Status of Women have already been made and ways of effecting further improvements are under examination.

Comment on this

I appreciate that the Parliamentary Secretary like those of us on this side of the House is conscious of the discrimination and the anomalies which exist in the social welfare code as applied to women. Can the Parliamentary Secretary tell the House when he intends abandoning these anomalies and bringing in legislation which will do away with them once and for all?

Comment on this

As the Deputy may be aware, in the Report on the Status of Women there were 15 recommendations made regarding the administration of social welfare benefits. Of those 15 recommendations, eight have been fully implemented; three have been partially implemented; three are under examination. One, in fact, was not implemented because the effect of implementing it would have worsened the position of women. I think the Deputy will agree that considerable progress has been made in two years in eradicating a very large number of anomalies which had existed over a long period of years. In fact, I am glad to say that recognition for the progress that has been made in this area was expressed by Dr. Thekla Beere and we are hoping, as I said in the reply, to eliminate all discrimination in full where it does exist, and the remaining recommendations which have not yet been dealt with are under examination.

Comment on this

Of course, we do not accept for one moment that the Parliamentary Secretary is discharging his functions in this respect—to some degree, yes. I wonder would the Parliamentary Secretary, for the benefit of myself and the House generally, place on the record of the House the 15 areas of recommendations which were made by the Commission. The Parliamentary Secretary has told the House that eight of the recommendations have been dealt with fully, a number have been partially dealt with and some remain to be dealt with. The Parliamentary Secretary, in common with a number of his comrades or brothers in Government, thinks that if the public are told something often enough and long enough they will believe it——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is deviating from the question.

Comment on this

I would appreciate if the Parliamentary Secretary would make that information available to me.

Comment on this

I regard all my colleagues in Coalition as comrades and all my fellow human beings as brothers. I have not the detailed information regarding the recommendations of the Commission on the Status of Women. The Deputy has shown an interest in this matter and undoubtedly he has read the report——

Comment on this

From cover to cover.

Comment on this

The 15 recommendations are embodied in the report and, therefore, they are readily available.

Comment on this

I appreciate that.

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary at least acknowledge that it was I who established the commission and appointed Dr. Thekla Beere as chairman?

Comment on this

I congratulate Deputy Haughey on his choice.

Comment on this

Surely the House is entitled to know which of the eight recommendations have been dealt with? Would the Parliamentary Secretary be good enough to let me know which areas have been dealt with?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We cannot debate this question all afternoon. We must make some progress.

Comment on this

I have asked the Parliamentary Secretary to let me have some information.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must allow the Chair to deal with Question Time in his own fashion without any interference.

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary please let me have a note regarding the eight areas that have been dealt with? Is that too much to ask?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy would give me an opportunity to answer the question. He did not request this information in his question and I have not the details immediately available. I am sure the Deputy has read the report of the Commission on the Status of Women. There is a section in that report listing the 15 recommendations made. I would be only too happy to communicate to the Deputy the eight recommendations that have been fully implemented, the three that have been partially implemented, the one recommendation it would not be in the best interests of the recipients to implement and the three that are under examination.

Comment on this