Military justice system changes
The Minister said no changes to the Defence Forces’ military-law system were under consideration. Mr. Dowling raised concerns about double and collective punishment, but the Chair stopped him from detailing a case and said he could pursue the matter on the Estimate or by notice on the Adjournment.
asked the Minister for Defence if it is proposed to change the present system of legal justice in the Defence Forces.
Comment on this
Proposals to change the system of military law provided for under the Defence Act, 1954, are not at present under consideration.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that there is this problem in relation to the last question of double punishment——
Comment on this
The Deputy may not go back on a question already disposed of. We are now on Question No. 36.
Comment on this
I am referring to this question. Arising out of Question No. 36, is it proposed to change the present system of legal justice in the Defence Forces? There are cases where double punishment is inflicted on individuals and I want to ask the Minister to change the whole system. In addition, there is this collective punishment, which is not intended, and I just want to give the Minister an indication of what happens when a CO walks into a room——
Comment on this
The Deputy is citing a case. The Deputy may not use Question Time for making statements.
Comment on this
I am merely indicating to the Minister there are cases of double punishment and the whole question of the legal code——
Comment on this
The Deputy may not continue in this way. This is a matter that would arise appropriately on the Estimate.