Legal aid for soldiers
Mr. Davern questioned the lack of military legal aid for accused soldiers and asked whether the position would be reviewed. The Minister cited an earlier legal committee’s view that an appeal system was unnecessary, while Mr. Davern clarified his concern about representation by an officer without legal qualifications; the Minister said he had sometimes removed reprimands to protect soldiers’ promotion prospects.
Does the Minister not think it is a bit unfair that a soldier is not entitled to any military legal aid while the prosecution have the full benefit of all the legal powers available?
Comment on this
This matter was dealt with at length by the Minister for Defence of the day, the late Deputy Oscar Traynor, during the proceedings of the Special Committee on the Defence Bill. The Minister stated that the matter was so important he submitted it for examination to a committee of three lawyers—one nominated by the Attorney General, a second by the Minister for Justice and the third by himself—and that they had advised him that a system of appeal from conviction by court martial was neither necessary nor desirable.
The Minister also referred to the extensive procedure being provided for the fullest consideration of charges against a soldier and the different steps by which, at every stage, mis-carriages of justice were guarded against. In particular, he mentioned that under the provisions of the Bill the findings and sentence of a court martial are not valid until confirmed by a confirming authority; a superior authority may, after a sentence has actually been confirmed, mitigate or remit the punishment or substitute a proper or a lesser punishment; certain sentences may also be suspended and eventually the punishment remitted; the Minister has power to quash the findings and sentence of a court martial where it appears to him that the proceedings were illegal or the accused was wrongfully convicted; the Minister may also direct a retrial; provision is made for the presentation of petitions by or on behalf of persons sentenced by court martial; the Minister gets the advice of the Attorney General as to any action which may be taken by him. The procedure regarding the presentation of petitions has worked well over the years.
Comment on this
That is not exactly what I had in mind, but is the Minister aware that a soldier has two choices: he can pick a civilian solicitor or an officer of his choice? The latter will have no legal qualifications——