Tax on an £8,000 house
The Minister estimated VAT at £236 and said income tax could not be calculated without details of the business and applicable deductions. Members disputed the VAT estimate, compared it with housing grants, and sought an itemised breakdown; the Minister offered to provide one upon receipt of an appropriate question.
asked the Minister for Finance the amount of VAT and income tax collected by the State in respect of the erection of an £8,000 house.
Comment on this
The value-added tax collected in the erection of an £8,000 house is £236.
Income tax is a tax chargeable on a person in respect of income or profits. The amount payable in any one case depends on the particular circumstances applying in the conduct of the business and in relation to allowances and deductions and it is not possible, therefore, to state what element of income tax may be contained in any one transaction.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say what the difference would be between the amount of VAT collected and the amount of State grant given for an £8,000 house?
Comment on this
I have not got that information before me but my own view of the matter is that the State grant exceeds the amount of VAT collected.
Comment on this
Leaving percentages aside for one moment it seems to me that it could vary from £50 to £100.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that £50 would be more correct than £100? In fact, the value of the new house grant is £50.
Comment on this
Even for that type of house it would depend on a number of things including the income of the person.
Comment on this
The Minister is aware that the income of the person is not taken into consideration for the State grant?
Comment on this
I will show the Minister some figures which will prove that that is not correct. The amount being charged is quite substantially more.
Comment on this
The appropriate rate of tax would be 2.95 but I will be only too happy to consider any figures submitted by the Deputy.
Comment on this
Taking one thing with another the average figure of VAT on a new house is less than 3 per cent.
Comment on this
Would the Minister make available to the House an itemised breakdown of how the VAT has been collected?
Comment on this
I will be only too happy, on receipt of an appropriate question, to furnish that information.