We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Intervention Beef.

Representations on beef intervention restrictions

Summary

Gibbons asked whether the Minister had received representations before restricting beef sent into intervention. Clinton said there had been no formal representations, but the Commission was concerned about Ireland’s heavy reliance on intervention and the lack of commercial sales. Members disputed whether the restrictions targeted Ireland and would harm cattle prices; Clinton said other states were also affected, defended his efforts to resist changes, and said he could not use a veto.

asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if, prior to his announcement concerning the restriction of the quantities of beef being sent into intervention, he received representations in the matter from the EEC Commission or from any other agency.

Comment on this

No formal representations were received but my Department were aware from contacts with the Commission that the large proportion of Irish beef slaughterings continuing to be put into intervention at this time of year was a matter of some concern to the Commission. I and my Department were also becoming very concerned at the apparent lack of adequate efforts to develop commercial beef sales as against offerings to intervention, as well as the possibility that over-use of the intervention system would be bound to create not only physical storage problems but pressures for altering the system to our disadvantage in times of seasonally high supplies and weak market conditions.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not consider that his intemperate attack on the meat trade on their alleged failure to get out and sell, as he said, may well have hastened the decision of Commissioner Lardinois and the European Commission to introduce the draconian measures against Irish beef going into intervention of which we became aware yesterday?

Comment on this

This is more of the Deputy's imagination. We were only too well aware already of the pressures coming on the intervention system because of the cost of the Community's budget. It was in order to save this situation that I was putting some pressure on the processors to go out and sell beef in the market and not lose this expertise.

Comment on this

How is it that when the butter mountain was formed nothing happened like what is happening now to the beef men?

Comment on this

Or the wine lake?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a separate matter.

Comment on this

It is directed solely against Ireland and it will have a detrimental effect on cattle prices in the autumn.

Comment on this

That is another statement which is not true—that it is directed against Ireland only. These measures have been taken against other member states as well, not just against Ireland. Other member states are putting in 5 per cent whereas we are putting in 50 per cent and we would be putting in 65 per cent but for the fact that I restricted the intake.

Comment on this

This is not good enough. The Minister who is our representative in the Council of Ministers is attempting to justify the attitude of the Commission.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

A question, please.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not realise that 85 per cent of our total output has to be exported, whereas France and other meat producing countries are operating largely in an internal market?

Comment on this

The Deputy knows the efforts I have made and the extreme to which I have gone to resist any tampering with intervention because I am totally opposed to any attempt to erode the value of prices negotiated in the spring of the year. The Deputy knows that only too well. There is nothing I can do. The Commission have these powers through the management committee and they have used their powers. All I can do is to try to get that changed if it is possible.

Comment on this

The Minister has another power and he will have to use it, the power of the veto.

Comment on this

The power of the veto could not be used.

Comment on this

Of course it could.

Comment on this

The Commission did what they were perfectly entitled to do, unfortunately.

8.

Comment on this