We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Intervention Beef.

Reports of unusable Irish intervention beef

Summary

Crinion and Leonard asked about reports of intervention beef being destroyed or found unusable. Clinton said no Irish beef was involved in the Brussels report and that two press reports about Irish beef were unfounded, noting that those quoted had denied the claims. He acknowledged that inspection could not guarantee perfection in every case, defended Irish processors, and said properly frozen and stored beef should remain sound; he also rejected the suggestion that the reports prompted the Commission’s restrictions.

asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries the number of tons of intervention beef that had to be destroyed on reaching its final destination as indicated in the Brussels report (details supplied); the number of instances of meat of inferior quality that are being investigated; the number of tons of such meat that are held in intervention at present; if his attention has been drawn to a report (details supplied) that hunderds of tons of beef were not properly frozen and the action he proposes to take to safeguard this country's reputation as an exporter of high quality beef.

10.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if he will make a statement on the report to the effect that some Irish beef held in intervention was found to be in an unusable condition.

Comment on this

With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle I propose to take Questions Nos. 9 and 10 together.

I have seen the Press reference of Monday 28th April to a Brussels report of the destruction of intervention beef. I have no information about the beef referred to as no Irish intervention beef was involved. The Press article of Sunday 27th April referred to Irish beef in two specific instances which were without foundation; and the English butcher mentioned has since written to the London Office of C.B.F. stating that he was misquoted. My Department also issued a denial to the Press. As I mentioned in my reply to a Question by the Deputy on 22nd April, there have been some instances in which beef offered to intervention was not up to the required standard. Investigation of complaints about beef stored in intervention or sold out of intervention has been taking place in eight instances. It is not practicable to indicate the tonnage but the individual complaints relate to small lots.

I am satisfied that this country's reputation as an exporter of high quality beef will not suffer by reason of these isolated complaints.

Comment on this

Is it a fact that the officers of the Department have to pass the meat while it is going through the factory and before it goes into intervention? Why is the Minister saying it has only just come to his notice now when those agents were investigating the position? Should the Minister not have seen this long ago?

Comment on this

The Deputy must accept that in view of the fact that we slaughtered more than one million cattle, a figure never reached before, which required the degree of inspection, and that we took in more than 500,000 cattle into intervention, it would be impossible to expect that everything would be 100 per cent at all times. Some small things might slip here and there but I still hold that Irish processors are as good as any in Europe. I believe we are processing beef longer than any other member States for the American trade and doing it extremely well.

Comment on this

Is it a fact that some of those reports, even though the Minister is denying them now——

Comment on this

I am not denying them; the people alleged to have made them denied them.

Comment on this

——were the cause of the restrictions from the EEC Commission which came into operation in the last few days? Did that give the Commission the idea to put restrictions on us?

Comment on this

The Deputy is giving the impression, which is wrong, that there has been a complaint only about Irish intervention beef. There have been complaints about beef from other countries. This is only giving some credence to what has been said so irresponsibly in the British press.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that recordings are taken when meat goes into intervention and if the meat is in good condition when offered it leaves storage in that condition?

Comment on this

If the meat is frozen in time, dispatched correctly and if the correct temperatures are maintained while it is in storage the meat will be in order. What the Deputy said is correct, but we do not know that these things were 100 per cent in the isolated cases.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not agree that it is just another British slander on Irish products?

Comment on this

It certainly was a slander that was completely unwarranted.

Comment on this

The Minister should have refuted those allegations.

Comment on this

We publicly refuted those allegations, and so did the meat factories concerned.

Comment on this