Rural kiosks without post offices
The Minister rejected kiosk requests for several rural locations without post offices, saying demand determines priorities and local-authority guarantees remain an option. Deputies challenged the policy as harmful to rural communities and questioned shifting costs to ratepayers; the Minister declined to answer broader argumentative questions.
asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs if he proposes to erect telephone kiosks at Gurteenoona, Monasterevan and Lullymore, Rathangan, County Kildare.
9.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs if he will consider the erection of a public telephone kiosk at Cloughduv, County Cork.
10.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs if he will arrange for the provision of a public telephone kiosk at Kilruane, Nenagh, County Tipperary.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 8, 9 and 10 together.
Kiosks are not being provided in rural areas such as Gurteenoona, Lullymore, Cloughduv and Kilruane, where there are no post offices.
Comment on this
Is it departmental policy that the more out-of-the-way and rural an area is the less likelihood there is of a telephone kiosk being erected there?
Comment on this
As the House is aware, there is a question of demand and this means that kiosks are provided first in areas where there is demand for that service and only later in areas where there is very little demand. Of course, the same consideration applies to them—of which the House is now well aware— of provision under local authority guarantee and that possibility might be considered by those interested.
Comment on this
Is the Minister of opinion that local authorities should now undertake the provision of services which up to now were the responsibility of his Department?
Comment on this
No. It is not for me to indicate what local authorities should or should not do. I am merely indicating that the possibility exists. My Department has to maintain certain priorities and they are the same priorities as have always been maintained, at least for many years.
Comment on this
Does the Minister acknowledge the social needs of many areas which have not a sub-post office? Is it the policy of his Department that if there is no post office in a village, even if it is a big one, no kiosk will be erected in spite of the obvious needs of the community? Are the priorities in the Minister's Department financial ones, some of them not soundly based? Are the social needs of our communities being completely disregarded by the Minister?
Comment on this
That is a large and argumentative question and I do not think I should be called upon to enter into it in the wake of questions such as are before the House.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that the priority scheme operated by his Department works to the detriment of parts of rural Ireland?
Comment on this
Will the Minister state if it is the policy of his Department to add to the burden of the ratepayers in having county councils provide telephone kiosks at the expense of ratepayers when the emphasis should be on abolishing rates?
Comment on this
I am in some difficulty when argumentative general questions are put as supplementaries to quite precise questions. I am not attempting to tell the Ceann Comhairle his job but I am saying I do not propose to answer that type of question.
Comment on this
Will the Minister explain what he meant by a guarantee regarding the provision of telephone kiosks?
Comment on this
I have already told the Deputy that I have allowed a lot of latitude on this question. I am calling Question No. 11.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned this in his reply. Will he tell the House what he meant by a guarantee?
Comment on this
It is open to the Deputy to put down these questions. If Deputies will not put down their own questions but will coast along on other questions——
Comment on this
If county councils are obliged to subsidise telephone kiosks it is the ratepayers who must pay.