We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Laois VEC Dispute.

Laois VEC dispute and pending decision

Summary

The Minister said he had reviewed the legal advice and was considering the committee’s views, but gave no date for a decision. Members challenged the delay and disputed whether the teaching-experience rules were clear; the Minister maintained that qualifying service is measured at the time of competition.

asked the Minister for Education if he has, as yet, studied the legal advice offered last March to the Laois County Vocational Committee in relation to their dispute with him; and if he will now announce his decision in the matter.

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

I have seen the legal advice in question. It was discussed at the meeting of the County Laois Vocational Education Committee on 14th April, 1975, and their views thereon were conveyed to me in the minutes of that meeting. I am now considering the views of the committee and will be in touch with them in due course.

Comment on this

Is this what the Minister promised on the 11th February last when he said that he would determine this position on receipt of legal advice? Does he agree with a recent statement of the chairman of the Laois vocational committee in this regard that they have been proved right now and that the Minister has no justification?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

I would have to have evidence of any such statement before commenting, that is if I would comment at all.

Comment on this

The statement appeared in yesterday's edition of The Irish Times. Would the Minister agree with the claim that there is confusion regarding the regulations contained in memo V7 regarding teaching experience?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

There is no confusion in regard to the teaching regulations.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not aware that the majority of the committee in question are playing ducks and drakes with him and that the situation has been shown in this light in the national Press? By dallying in making the proper decision the Minister is suffering the ignominy of having those people laugh at him.

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

I am prepared to endure the laughter of people provided I get the right decision in the end.

Comment on this

Is it the laughter of fools?

Comment on this

Is it a question of giving way to the master of craw thumpers on the Minister's side of the House?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is introducing argument into the matter.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say when he will give a decision?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

In due course and when it is appropriate.

Comment on this

This matter has been going on for the past 12 months. In view of the overall clash between the majority of the committee and the Minister, surely it must be appropriate now to make a decision.

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

I am considering the views of the committee and will be in touch with them in due course.

Comment on this

Is it not true that the lapse of time may change this situation?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

If the Deputy would be specific on that, perhaps I could help him.

Comment on this

Is it not true that the question is one of the length of service necessary in order to qualify for the position concerned and that if the dispute continues long enough, the individual in question will have had enough service to qualify for appointment?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

I am surprised at the Deputy not realising that the length of service is that obtaining at the point of competition.

Comment on this

Deputy Oliver Flanagan says differently.

Comment on this

The Minister is simply shirking his responsibility.

Comment on this