Army officers’ pay increase
Loughnane challenged whether captains and commandants had received the 5% arbitration increase from 1 April 1974; Donegan said increases for officers up to commandant had been approved, while NCOs’ and men’s rates remained under discussion. Dowling repeatedly sought the approval date and challenged conflicting statements, but the Minister did not clarify it before the Chair ended the exchange; Loughnane’s question about retrospectivity was also left unanswered.
asked the Minister for Defence why Army captains and commandants did not receive the increase in pay from 1st April, 1974 equivalent to the increase for junior and senior executives of the civil service as was agreed by arbitration.
Comment on this
A pay increase in line with the civil service increase mentioned has been approved for officers up to and including the rank of commandant.
Comment on this
I did not hear the reply. I am very sorry. I could not hear with the references to subversives and Blue Shirts from Limerick.
Comment on this
The following is the reply:
A pay increase in line with the civil service increase mentioned has been approved for officers up to and including the rank of commandant.
Comment on this
That is a very unsatisfactory reply because civil servants got the pay increase and there was arbitration and the same rates of pay were to be paid to Army captains and commandants and it was not given to them. Would the Minister see to it that Army officers get this money that they are entitled to get?
Comment on this
The Deputy will realise that my best efforts will be made to look after the Army and to see that the best possible increases in pay in relation to the public service are provided for the Army. At this point in time—and I emphasise at this point in time—up to the rank of commandant we have got through and the question of NCOs and men is with the Department of the Public Service and we are trying to work out rates. It is not a question of saying, "OK, we will make 5p, 10p." It is quite difficult to get a comparison when there are different terms of service and different numbers of years of service involved. The House may be assured that as far as I and the Government are concerned the NCOs and men will get the very best we can give them. At the moment the matter is with the Department of the Public Service and is being worked on.
Comment on this
I am afraid that judging by the answer he has given the Minister is not familiar with the question. He has mentioned three times "this point in time". At the point in time that the civil servants got the increase in pay the Army should have got it and they did not get it. It is the Minister's duty to look after the interests of the Army.
Comment on this
Deputy Loughnane knows that if there was an argument about whether I owed him £1 or not, that £1 would be paid. Equally, if Deputy Loughnane owed me £1, that £1 would be paid as soon as the argument was over. I am telling him that the officers are looked after and that, in fact, the case of the NCOs and men is with the Department of the Public Service. That does not mean that they will not get their money.
Comment on this
The Minister has indicated that the increase has been granted to officers. Can he state the date on which the increase was granted?
Comment on this
The increase follows from the grant at arbitration of an increase of 5 per cent with effect from 1st April, 1974.
Comment on this
The question refers to captains and commandants. On 1st May the Minister indicated that the payment of increases of 5 per cent to captains and commandants was still under consideration.
Comment on this
The Minister is either misleading the House now or was misleading it on 1st May when he indicated that the matter was still under consideration. That was in his reply to the Estimate debate. Now he tells us that they have, in fact, been paid this increase.
Comment on this
All I want to know is the date on which the Minister or the Minister for Finance approved the increase.
Comment on this
This matter has been raised on several occasions. I merely want to extract from the Minister the date on which this was approved by the Minister or by the Minister for Finance. Was it between 1st May and today?
Comment on this
The Minister has indicated that the increases have been granted. Now the Minister is going to look at it. Is the Minister telling us now that he does not know whether in fact the increases have been granted or not?
Comment on this
The Minister found a mistake yesterday evening in the unrevised Official Report. A figure of £15 million was printed as £50 million. The Minister is not God Almighty. He will do his best.
Comment on this
It may well be but the Deputy must find another opportunity of raising it. Item No. 11.
Comment on this
We want to know, in fact, if the increases have been granted and the date on which the increases were granted by the Minister.
Comment on this
We are trying to get factual information. Are you satisfied that the Minister is misleading the House?
Comment on this
This may not matter to you but it is a question of a pay increase going back to 1st April, 1974.
Comment on this
Deputy Dowling, it is a fundamental part of the rules of this House that when the Chair rises the Deputy in possession will resume his seat. The Deputy must resume his seat forthwith or leave the House.