We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - State Borrowings.

Exchequer overdrafts and borrowing policy

Summary

Ryan explained that the £172 million in “Other Borrowings” was gross temporary Central Bank overdraft borrowing, offset by £116 million in repayments, leaving £56 million net. Challenged over the scale and risks of borrowing amid inflation and sterling’s decline, he defended short-term borrowing during the oil-related shock and global recession, arguing that the alternative would cause severe economic and social distress.

asked the Minister for Finance if he will state in respect of the figure of £172 million under the heading of "Other Borrowings" in the table of receipts into the Exchequer between 1st January and 13th May, 1975 (a) the names of the banks and countries involved (b) the reason for the extent of such borrowing as compared with the corresponding figure for last year of only £3.69 million (c) the interest rates and (d) the repayment date of each loan.

Comment on this

The figure of £172 million mentioned by the Deputy is a gross borrowing figure against which should be set the repayment figure of £116 million on the issues side of the Exchequer statement. The net figure is £56 million. The money has been advanced to the Exchequer under temporary overdraft facilities by the Central Bank. As this facility was extended only towards the end of last year, the figures for the period up to 13th May, 1974, would not have contained any comparable amounts. The interest rate is the same as the Associated Banks AAA overdraft rate which varies from time to time but which on 13th May, stood at 10¾ per cent. As the facility is on a day-to-day basis there is no set repayment date that specific advances must be repaid as quickly as possible but at any rate within a year.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not worried that the Government are borrowing at the rate of £10 million per week? How long will the Government be able to continue doing this before the country is bankrupt?

Comment on this

The Deputy is aware that the opinion of every international institution of repute is that a country like Ireland, affected by the oil imbalance, should borrow in the short term. It is the Government's long publicised strategy to borrow in present circumstances but to reduce the borrowing over a period.

Comment on this

Will the Minister state if that advice is still being given against the background of the declining value of the £ and a galloping rate of inflation of up to 25 per cent? Surely the Minister will agree that is economic nonsense?

Comment on this

It is not possible to look at any particular economic force in isolation. As the Deputy knows, they are inter-related. What I have said about the Government's economic policy is still true, namely, that our circumstances require borrowing on a more substantial scale now than anything we experienced previously. The alternative to such borrowing would be to cause a devastating slump in the economy which would have the most harmful economic and social effects. The Government are very carefully assessing the situation and, as the requirements of the day dictate, borrowings will be made according to our capacity to repay as well as current needs.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not agree that is dangerous gambling?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

It is dangerous and irresponsible.

Comment on this

No. It would be much more dangerous to cause massive economic and social distress from which it would take this country many years to recover.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): Whatever justification there may be for excessive borrowing on a capital budget, surely the Minister will agree it is economic disaster to continue to borrow excessively on a current budget?

Comment on this

There are circumstances where borrowing on a current budget is fully justified and there are very few countries in the world, other than the OPEC countries, that are not doing so today. If countries followed the Fianna Fáil prescription the world recession, which today is worse than anything previously experienced, would be immeasurably worse.

Comment on this

Is it not true that the other countries to which the Minister has referred have come to grips with and have overcome their inflationary problems and that rather than devaluing their currencies they are maintaining and increasing their values?

Comment on this

I do not know of any country that has come to grips with or has solved its inflationary problems. Because of the economic recession throughout the world, countries are being forced to operate with unprecedented deficits on current budgets. If they did not do so the distress in the world would be much greater than it is.

Comment on this

Is it not true that of the EEC countries, the United States and many of the OECD countries only Britain and Ireland have failed to conquer the problem of inflation?

Comment on this

I would not say the others have conquered the problem. They have been more successful in controlling their rate of inflation.

Comment on this

They have turned the graph in their favour.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We cannot debate this question all afternoon. I am calling Question No. 18.

Comment on this

The forecasts made by several countries earlier in the year have not materialised and they have been less successful than they thought they would be.

Comment on this

All of these countries have been able to achieve a decrease in the inflationary trend and the graph has turned in their favour.

Comment on this

They are moving in the right direction and we also will soon move in the right direction.

Comment on this