Arterial drainage cost-benefit studies
The Maigue study is complete and the Corrib-Mask-Robe study is nearing completion; no other listed catchments have been assessed. Kenny said cost-benefit analysis may improve their prospects compared with the former method, confirmed land scarcity is considered, and offered Blaney a fuller explanation.
asked the Minister for Finance the progress that has been made on the cost/benefit analysis of the rivers on the arterial drainage list which was commenced some years ago.
Comment on this
The cost/benefit study of drainage proposals for the Maigue catchment has been completed and when the report has been edited I shall arrange to have it available in the Dáil Library. The study for the Corrib-Mask-Robe area is well advanced.
Comment on this
In this study have all the rivers listed for arterial drainage treatment been completed?
Comment on this
No. Before further arterial drainage is carried out a cost/ benefit analysis must be carried out on the particular catchment.
Comment on this
Is the Parliamentary Secretary aware that in the time of his predecessor, in relation to rivers far down the list, probably about 25th or 26th, as far as my recollection serves me, 2½ or 3 years ago a cost/ benefit analysis was to be put in hand? Such does not seem to have happened and is not likely to happen in the foreseeable future.
Comment on this
Are we to take it these rivers low down on the list are not likely to be done for many years to come?
Comment on this
The Deputy is confused about this. The rivers are surveyed but cost/benefit analysis has not been carried out on the rivers that are far down the list. The first cost/ benefit analysis that was carried out was finished only last October. That was on the Maigue. The second one is on the Corrib-Mask-Robe and that will be finished within a month or two. No other river that is on the list has been cost/benefit surveyed. Does the Deputy understand what I mean?
Comment on this
I understand the Parliamentary Secretary's reply but what I am still trying to find out is what hope there is of rivers that are down the list being done in the foreseeable future. I refer not only to cost/benefit analysis but to actual work being carried out. If cost/benefit analysis has any meaning I take it that the proposition is that quite a number of those on the list may fail on the basis of cost/benefit analysis and will not be regarded as worthy of being drained. Since the process of cost/ benefit analysis appears to be so slow and as only three rivers have so far been subjected to this examination, one would have thought that the others would be in process of being analysed so that they would take their place up the list as others were eliminated.
Comment on this
What the Deputy must understand is that under cost-benefit analysis a catchment area has a better chance of being favourably decided upon than under the former method of rule of thumb.
Comment on this
May I make one further point of clarification? Under cost-benefit analysis the rivers that have not been done stand a better chance of having a favourable decision given in respect of them than under the former method of rule of thumb.
Comment on this
I am sorry for persisting in this. May I ask the Parliamentary Secretary whether in the application of the cost-benefit analysis procedure consideration is given to the areas in which lands would be made useful by drainage where land is more scarce than in other areas?
Comment on this
This is a very complicated subject. I will meet the Deputy and I will give him a full and accurate explanation. I can give the information but I cannot supply the comprehension here.