We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - EEC Beef Imports.

EEC beef imports and the veto

Summary

Dr. Gibbons and other Deputies challenged the handling of the Commission’s decision to permit beef imports from third countries, asking why it was not treated as a matter requiring unanimity and whether Ireland could use a veto. Minister Clinton said the Commission had already acted within its Treaty competence; the Council could amend or annul the decision only by qualified majority, so a veto was unavailable. He said the veto could apply to proposals, not this decision, and that he could not alter the Treaty.

asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if, at the beginning of the meeting of Ministers which accepted the proposal of the EEC Commission to permit the importation of beef from third countries, it was decided to distinguish items on the agenda requiring decision by unanimity under the Treaty as indicated in the answer to Question No. 36 on 4th February, 1975; and, if not, why the stated procedure was not followed, in view of the fact that the proposal was one of vital national importance for the State.

49.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if he indicated to the Council of Ministers that the EEC Commission's proposal for the importation of beef from third countries was a matter of vital national interest to Ireland and as such was a proposal to which he found it necessary to apply the veto.

Comment on this

With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 48 and 49 together.

I would point out to the Deputy that the matter before the Council was a decision that had already been taken by the Commission within its competence under the beef regulation. Consideration by the Council of this decision did not require unanimity of voting and the question of a veto did not arise. The Commission's decision could be amended or annulled by a qualified majority vote of the Council but in fact in the vote which took place such a majority supported the Commission.

Comment on this

If this matter comes up in future will it be the same approach?

Comment on this

I am afraid so because it is within the Commission's competence. It was a decision, not a set of proposals from the Commission.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that no matter what they do he will never attempt to use the veto?

Comment on this

There are certain things within the Commission's competence. These things can be brought to the Council on the request of a member state if the application to have them brought is made within three days. There can then be a discussion at the Commission and they can be amended or annulled on a qualified majority basis, but not by using veto. When the decision is made, even if a veto is used, it means no action is taken on the decision.

Comment on this

Do we take it that there is different procedure in dealing with the Agriculture Committee from that dealing with the Foreign Affairs Committee?

Comment on this

Not on questions on which the Commission have the right of decision.

Comment on this

I understood the Minister for Foreign Affairs stated here that before decisions were taken an agenda was analysed and matters of importance to each nation were put up. Those were for unanimous decisions and non-unanimous decisions. Could this not be followed at future meetings of the Ministers for Agriculture before decisions are taken?

Comment on this

It could provided we were dealing with proposals and not decisions. This was a decision that was within the competence of the Commission already. That was only being discussed on the request of a member state. This is a very different situation altogether.

Comment on this

May we assume that this decision, which is the basis of all this questioning, will terminate the effect of this and next year there will again be a proposal followed by a subsequent decision? Can the veto not be used at that time?

Comment on this

No, it can only be used at the time of the proposal.

Comment on this

Will the Minister guarantee to the House and the public that he will do that the next time?

Comment on this

This is something that is in the Treaty, which is within the competence of the Commission. I can do nothing to alter the Treaty.

Comment on this

To whom are the Commission responsible in matters like this?

Comment on this

They are not responsible to the Council.

Comment on this

Are they not responsible to anybody?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Question No. 50.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that this question of veto is just something on paper and nothing else?

Comment on this

No, but there are instances where the veto cannot be used. I am saying there are certain things within the competence of the Commission.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We must pass on to the next question. Question No. 50.

Comment on this

What would the Minister consider a matter of great national importance to the country if this question of the agricultural market was not one?

Comment on this

It is not a matter, as I told the Deputies, that can be dealt with in the way suggested by them.

Comment on this