Mayo development farmer classification
Mayo had 1,936 applicants, of whom 871 were classified and 24 as development farmers. Deputies argued the EEC scheme excluded most western farmers and sought changes; the Minister agreed it needed adjustment but said Ireland must demonstrate its shortcomings and win other member states’ support.
andMr. Calleary asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries (a) the number of farmers in County Mayo who have applied for classification as development farmers (b) the percentage to date who have been classified and (c) the estimated final percentage of farmers expected to be classified as development farmers for the purpose of the appropriate EEC Directive.
Comment on this
At 30th April last, 1936 farmers in County Mayo had applied to participate in the farm modernisation scheme. The number of these applicants then classified for the purpose of the scheme was 871 of whom 24 or 3 per cent were in the development category. It would not be possible at this stage to say what number of farmers in the county might eventually be classified as development farmers. The recent introduction of a lower comparable income figure for western counties, together with the impending implementation of the directive on disadvantaged areas should result in a significant increase in the numbers qualifying for development status.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is now aware from the figures which he has before him—out of 871 in Mayo 24 are development farmers— that the directive is not suitable for this country? As far as I know the income figure is £1,700. In the figures published by the Agricultural Institute the average for the whole country was only £1,500 but it still will not bring in very many in the western counties. Would the Minister not consider an intermediate scheme, as the directive seems to be excluding the vast majority of farmers in the western region?
Comment on this
I want to say in reply to Deputy Callanan that the scheme is not mine nor was it my predecessor's because it was adopted eight months before we entered the Community. It is an EEC scheme, which we cannot just change overnight. I have said on numerous occasions before that there is no point in our going for any significant changes in this scheme until we can say we have proved in practice over a period of at least 12 months that it is unsuitable in so many different ways. This is the only way we can put up a convincing argument and we intend to do this.
Comment on this
I am trying to be brief. I do not want to hold up the House very long but this is an important supplementary. Is the Minister now convinced that the directive is completely unsuitable for this country? He should be convinced now after giving it a try. What effort does he intend making to try to have these directives changed.
Comment on this
I am convinced that the scheme needs to be changed if it is to be more suitable for this country but it represents a significant improvement on what was available to farmers prior to its introduction.
Comment on this
When the Minister says he agrees it needs to be changed does he not think that an immediate change is necessary if damage is not to be done to farming organisations before the change is made?
Comment on this
Deputy Leonard will have to accept that it is not sufficient for me to be convinced that an immediate change is necessary in the case of Ireland. I have to convince eight other member states as well that this is so. We have the best scheme, incidentally. We have used the variable aspect of this to the extent that we have by far the best scheme in Europe.
4.