New Jobs and Manufacturing Employment
The Minister cited an IDA estimate of 16,000 manufacturing jobs created in 1974 against about 20,000 job losses, a preliminary net loss of 4,000. He explained that job creation differs from actual recruitment and that unemployment also reflects new labour-market entrants and losses elsewhere; an economic upturn was forecast, but its employment effects would lag. He lacked some requested figures and rejected a Deputy’s call to consider resigning.
(Dublin Central) asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce the number of new jobs created in the year ended March, 1975.
Comment on this
I presume the Deputy is referring to new jobs created in manufacturing industry.
It is difficult to make a close estimate of new job creation in industry because of the time-lag between approval of new projects and their realisation. However, on the best information available to them, the Industrial Development Authority estimate that in the calendar year 1974, the latest period for which an estimate is available, about 16,000 new jobs were created in manufacturing industry.
Comment on this
Can the Minister state how the increase in new jobs compares with job losses in existing industries?
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate that there are a number of inputs in the context of rising unemployment. So far as we can estimate—this is from the IDA survey rather than from Central Statistics Office figures—the number of job losses was about 20,000. Therefore, the net number of jobs losses is about 4,000. This is a first estimate.
Comment on this
How would the Minister relate the net loss of about 4,000 jobs to the fact that there are now about twice as many on the unemployed register compared with this time last year, that is, 120,000 compared with 60,000?
Comment on this
I did not develop that point when replying to the previous supplementary. In regard to the total number on the register, there are such factors as young persons coming on to the labour market, people leaving agriculture and downturns in the service sectors. As the opening sentence of my reply indicated, I am talking here of new jobs created in the manufacturing industry. That is the reason for the difference.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): About three weeks ago I tabled a question to the Minister asking for information as to the number of factories which closed in the year in question. I was told that 56 factories closed with a loss of 3,600 jobs. Is the figure of 16,000 in addition to those 3,600?
Comment on this
One tries to give an answer to the question asked but I cannot give a definite answer to that supplementary. There would be a difference between jobs lost in factories closing down and jobs lost where the numbers fell by way of natural wastage or where there were redundancies without the factories being closed.
Comment on this
Has the Minister any idea of what will be the trend in the coming year both in respect of job creations and job losses?
Comment on this
We are now in the sixth month of the year. To take the situation for a twelve-month period, the predictions are for an upturn in the third quarter of 1975, becoming more marked in the last quarter of this year and in the first quarter of 1976 although the experts in this field in various parts of the world have been in conflict with each other. It is fair to say that when this economic upturn occurs there is a little time lag before it translates itself into new jobs or into a reduction of unemployment.
Comment on this
There are a number of Deputies offering but I must indicate that, having allowed a good deal of time on this question, I am moving on to the next one.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would clarify one point. He gave a figure of 16,000 for new jobs in the manufacturing industry but can he say whether this means 16,000 people at work?
Comment on this
No. The term as used is "new job creation". The point the Deputy is making is important because there is a time lag between the creation of new jobs in terms of the agreement for an investment in an enterprise and the recruitment of staff which usually takes place in a phased way over a fairly long period of time. Therefore, the figure for new job creation in a twelve-month period is always different from the number for the recruitment of individuals. The two figures are frequently confused.
Comment on this
Would it not be possible for the IDA or for the Department to compile statistics giving the number of new jobs under way at a particular time?
Comment on this
Can the Minister say how many jobs were created and how many people began employment?
Comment on this
I will get the best answer possible for the most recent period but I have not got the information here.
Comment on this
Having presided over an industrial arm in which 20,000 jobs were lost in one year, would the Minister for Industry and Commerce consider objectively whether he should resign?