We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Textile, Clothing and Footwear Industries.

International constraints on textile industries

Summary

The Minister said tariffs or import quotas would breach EEC obligations, and that Italy’s deposit measures were permitted only during a balance-of-payments crisis. He rejected claims that Ireland faced such a crisis; the exchange also included a procedural objection and disagreement over a Taoiseach quotation.

asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce if he will outline in general terms the constraints imposed by international obligations which are compounding the present difficulties in the textile, clothing and footwear industries.

Comment on this

I would refer the Deputy to what I said in the Dáil on 4th December last when I dealt with this problem in some detail.

Quantitative restrictions or increased tariffs on imports, which are the remedies most frequently proposed for the present difficulties in various sectors of industry—particularly in the textile, clothing and footwear sectors—would be contrary to our Treaty obligations, especially those arising under the Act of Accession to the EEC.

In effect, we have to rely on Article 135 of the Act of Accession to the EEC which provides that the EEC Commission may, in the period to 31st December, 1977, authorise us to take protective measures in the event of serious difficulties arising in particular sectors of the economy. I have made the strongest possible representations to the Commission over an extended period but the Commission has not been prepared to authorise such measures on behalf of our textiles, clothing and footwear industries, because other member States are faced with the same difficulties in these sectors as we are and any concession granted to us could lead to a serious reaction throughout the Community. It is necessary, in this matter, to bear in mind the extent to which the economy of this country depends on exports. Statistics show that even in the very sensitive sectors mentioned there are areas where the value of our exports exceeds that of imports. We would, accordingly, be vulnerable to retaliatory action by other States in response to protective measures in our case especially if these measures were taken contrary to the commitments we have entered into.

Comment on this

Before supplementary questions are put, may I refer you to the Standing Orders in relation to the putting of Questions? Standing Order 36 says:

A question shall be put by a member rising in his place, and indicating the number of the Question on the Order Paper.

The Deputy who put that question, or on whose behalf the question was put, which would probably be more accurate, has not conformed to the Standing Order. I know the lady Member in question probably has something else to do but I make this point to indicate that, with the exception of Deputy Hogan O'Higgins having come in about one minute ago, the benches opposite have been completely empty during the whole of Question Time.

Comment on this

Did the Minister not tell Deputy Mrs. Desmond that he put down the question in her name?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

Would the Minister having replied to this quite obviously planted question, outline in general terms the efforts he has made to overcome the constraints imposed by international obligations which are compounding the present difficulties in the textile, clothing and footwear industries?

Comment on this

I wonder if the Deputy would wait for Question No. 12, in his name, asking me to outline the details of my contacts with the EEC Commission and the UK authorities, which I will be doing in the next answer?

Comment on this

Could I ask the Minister whether any other member State of the EEC has taken steps to restrict the import into their country of clothing, footwear or textiles, steps which were not taken by this Government?

Comment on this

I believe that the system of deposits, as distinct from quantitative restrictions—the system of deposits introduced by the Italians —was introduced in circumstances where they declared a balance of payments difficulty. That was under Articles 108 and 109 of the Rome Treaty. Those are steps that we do not propose to take. I know of no other steps taken by member States which have not been taken by us.

Comment on this

In regard to the steps taken by the Italian Government, is the Minister aware of any retaliatory action taken by other governments as a consequence?

Comment on this

I am not so aware. The Deputy will be aware that in invoking Articles 108 and 109 what the Italians did they did with the approval of the Commission in circumstances of a balance of payments crisis, which is what is specifically catered for under Articles 108 and 109. The Deputy will be aware that the damage to this country of declaring a balance of payments crisis where there is not one, for the purpose of protecting certain sectors of our industry, would be much greater than any possible good we would gain.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that the Taoiseach some months ago referred to the fact that proportionately our balance of payments deficit was greater than that of any other country in the EEC?

Comment on this

If the Deputy is trying to indicate that we have a balance of payments crisis——

Comment on this

I am quoting what the Taoiseach said.

Comment on this

——first, he is wrong and, secondly, he is harmful.

Comment on this

What did the Minister say?

Comment on this

It is a harmful suggestion. To suggest that there is a balance of payments crisis is harmful.

Comment on this

Is the Minister denying that the Taoiseach said that or is he saying that the Taoiseach was wrong?

Comment on this

I am not going to comment on a quotation given by the Deputy without references, without quoting, off the top of his head, as a gloss on what the Taoiseach said.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that the Taoiseach did not say it or, if he did, that he was acting harmfully?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That would not be relevant to the question on the Order Paper. Deputy Cunningham, a brief supplementary. I am anxious to make some progress.

Comment on this