We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Textile, Clothing and Footwear Industries.

Minister’s EEC and UK discussions

Summary

The Minister listed his discussions with the EEC Commission and UK authorities, saying the Commission had rejected Ireland’s Article 135 approach. He disputed claims that the task force had said remedies were in his hands, expressed disappointment with the Commission’s response, and promised to press the case again.

asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce the dates of his discussions in the past six months with the EEC Commission and the UK authorities in connection with the problems facing the footwear and textile industries; the particular aspects discussed on each occasion; and the outcome.

Comment on this

I had discussions with the EEC Commission and the UK authorities in connection with the problems facing the clothing, textile and footwear industries on the following dates within the last six months:

2nd December, 1974 — Meeting with five EEC Commissioners in Brussels; 9th/10th December, 1974 — Meeting with EEC Commission task force in Dublin; 14th January, 1975 — Meeting with Commissioner Gundelach in Dublin; 21st January, 1975 — Meeting with Commissioner Gundelach in Brussels; 29th January, 1975 and 6th February, 1975 — Discussion with Commissioner Gundelach; 10th February, 1975 — Meeting with Mr. Peter Shore UK Secretary of State for Trade in Brussels.

That was my personal participation but the contacts have been continued at high level in my Department and they are continuing. The matters under discussion at all of these meetings were the problems of the footwear, clothing and textile sectors, and the measures which might be taken to remedy these problems.

I have indicated previously the measures which were being taken to help the sensitive sectors of industry in so far as we were free to do so within the constraints imposed by our international obligations. These include anti-dumping investigations, adjustments of the quota licences for textile piece goods from 16 Far Eastern and Eastern European countries, more intensive checking of imports by the Revenue Commissioners, a restraint arrangement with South Korea in regard to exports of shirts from that country and the early introduction of a formal system of surveillance on imports of certain clothing, footwear and textile goods.

Comment on this

Will the Minister not agree that while these discussions have been going on the footwear and textile industries have been collapsing? Will he impress on the EEC the absolute need to change regulations that are damaging our economy?

Comment on this

I heard with some wry amusement — which did not give me any pleasure — the speeches from the Opposition with regard to this matter. I could have taken paragraphs from them and quoted identical arguments which I had made to the Commission and to the British. It is with great regret that I say the rejection of our approach under Article 135 which was conveyed to me on 14th January by Commissioner Gundelach was confirmed on the following day as the position of the Commission as a whole. I am familiar with the arguments the Opposition have made. I made them myself. I can fairly say there was no point made from the Opposition that I had not used in endeavouring to impress the seriousness of the situation on Brussels and on Britain.

Comment on this

Is it a fact that the task force told the Minister that the remedy largely lay in his own hands, that he could take action in relation to certain types of imports but that he was insisting on the EEC as a whole taking the action?

Comment on this

That is not so. The task force told me I could do three things, some of which we were doing already and all of which we are now doing.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that everyone involved in the discussions appears to believe that the task force told the Minister the remedy was in his own hands and that the reason no action was taken was that the Minister was insisting on the EEC taking the action?

Comment on this

That is absolutely not the case.

Comment on this

Will the Minister state if the occasions which he has detailed in which he personally participated in discussions on this matter, except, perhaps, the first occasion, came after the introduction and discussion here of a motion tabled by our party which called on him to do so?

Comment on this

I would indicate the text of the question to the Deputy which refers to discussions within the last six months. The question has been down for a few days and it was drawn up a little while ago. I could have excluded the meeting on 2nd December, 1974 from the list on the basis that it is now more than six months ago. I was answering the question asked.

Comment on this

The Minister did not exclude it.

Comment on this

The contracts and the difficulties in different sectors of our industry extend far beyond the six months to which the question refers.

Comment on this

Is the Minister stating that the EEC Commission took no cognisance of the fact that we are by far the weakest economy of the nine member States? Does he not consider that in these very difficult trading times they should give particular consideration to a country where there is so much unemployment and where certain industries are collapsing?

Comment on this

I was very disappointed with the response of the Commission. I made it clear to them at the time and I am happy to make it clear now.

Comment on this

Will the Minister make a further effort in this matter?

Comment on this

Certainly I will make a further effort. They have comparative figures for the industries and the level of unemployment in all of the countries. If we make that comparison they are able to say that although we are the smallest we are not the weakest. There are countries where unemployment has reached ten times as much as it is here.

Comment on this