Offaly textile redundancies and import protection
The Minister confirmed that nearly 100 redundancies were issued, citing falling domestic orders, and said import restrictions were constrained by Ireland’s treaty obligations. He described existing quotas and other protective measures, while rejecting calls for stronger action that could prompt damaging trade retaliation; Connolly disputed the Government’s timing and responsibility.
asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce if he is aware of the further redundancies that are about to take place in a firm (name supplied) in County Offaly, which will result in the loss of 100 jobs; and if he has any proposals under consideration to protect this industry from foreign trading difficulties.
Comment on this
I regret that the firm, to which the Deputy refers, have found it necessary recently to issue redundancy notices to nearly 100 of their workers. These redundancies are, I understand, largely due to a falling off in orders for one of their principal products on the home market.
I have indicated previously, in reply to similar questions, and I would refer the Deputy particularly to columns 519 and 2111 of the Dáil Debates of 16th January and 15th May, 1975 respectively, the action which is being taken, within the constraints imposed by our international treaty obligations, to help certain sensitive sectors of industry including textiles. This firm would benefit from the results of this action.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that the company called a recent Press conference at which it was stated that if imports were not curtailed or completely shut out the company would have to close? Is he also aware that the closing of the Blarney Mills in Cork had an adverse effect on them as they used to supply these mills?
Comment on this
I am aware of various statements calling for the complete shutting out of imports but I have made it clear that while we have, in regard to all the possible headings, done a large number of things to protect the textile industry and various sectors of it, the hope of total exclusion of imports is vain. It is not in our power without breaching the Treaty of Accession to the Community in a way that would provoke an instant retaliation from the Community. It is simply not in our power to do that within the terms of the Accession Treaty. The powers of retaliation of the Community, through the court and in other ways, are very substantial and where other countries have tried to do these things, they have used these powers promptly, so that the thought of the whole gamut from grants to loans to export promotion, help with design, management advice through the NDC—all of those things and the more recent things we have done such as surveillance and tightening up by the Revenue Commissioners are available to help the firm but to say that we could shut out competing imports is to raise a vain hope.
Comment on this
Is the Minister not aware that his primary duty as Minister is to protect the jobs of workers and employees and to cope with any retaliatory methods by the EEC countries as he meets them afterwards?
Comment on this
This question is very important in relation to the large number of industries which have closed down.
Comment on this
I can go into this in detail if Deputies wish it, but in relation to the firm in question or to any other exporting firm, the counselling of a course of action which would provoke retaliation which could be dealt with, as the Deputy suggested, as it arises is mistaken. There is only one country in the Community more dependent on foreign trade than we are, that is Belgium which has a much stronger economy, and to provoke an avalanche of protective measures on the part of adjoining countries to which we export would really—I know the Deputy does not wish it nor does any Deputy—inflict much greater harm on industry and employment than to proceed with the mechanisms. I am not any more satisfied with them than other Deputies but they are the only course open to us and recourse to violation of the Treaty and the provocation of retaliation would produce a much worse end result and a much greater threat to employment.
Comment on this
But if you are dealing with South Korea and countries like that, to which our exports are very small, there can be no significant retaliation by them?
Comment on this
I agree, but the Deputy should be aware that the 16 countries of the so-called low-cost quota area which includes the Far East low-cost producers, do not include Korea, with which we have made a separate arrangement. But they include the others. There are two things: first, there is the continuation of the quota order restricting imports to £100,000 per annum which, in terms of our total production, is very small, and, secondly, we have restructured the permission given under that £100,000 quota to admit only things which complement and do not complete with our own production. In regard to them we are doing something, and in regard to South Korea, which is not included in the low-cost quotas, we were the first, and we are still the only country to have obtained special arrangements through the Community for our restriction which has brought down, in the period since February when we invoked it, the import, for example, of South Korean shirts—woven shirts—to a total of 3,000 dozen, a little over 30,000 shirts which in terms of total production and consumption is very small. In the areas where action is possible we have acted in those two specific ways.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that the company stated that if they did not receive immediate help they would have to close with a loss of 380 jobs? In reference to the Minister's reply it was only after constant pressure from us on this side of the House that he decided to take action of the nature which we in Private Members' Time requested last December. He left it until now and the onus is on him and on the Government for the situation. It is shameful that the Minister and the Government carried on in that way.