Cost and scope of prescribed anthologies
Tunney challenged the prescription of a £3 anthology containing far more material than the 12 poems required for the pass course. Bruton defended the educational value of broader selections, agreed the apparent mismatch seemed strange, and said he would have it reviewed; the Chair then closed the remaining questions.
asked the Minister for Education if he will ensure that anthologies of prose and poetry costing £3, most of which are irrelevant and unnecessary to the examination course, will not be prescribed for future leaving certificate examinations.
Comment on this
A restriction of the type implied in the question would be educationally undesirable since it would withhold from the pupil the facility for immediate literary and cultural comparison and seriously inhibit the scope, breadth and value of the teacher's work in class.
Comment on this
Is the Parliamentary Secretary aware—and he indicated earlier that he has a function in the matter of prescribed anthologies—that, in respect of the anthology of Irish poems and prose, prescribed by the Department, the cost of the book is £3?
Comment on this
But the Parliamentary Secretary indicated earlier this was one area in which the Department had a function. Is he telling me now he is not aware of the fact that, in respect of pass leaving certificate, a book containing 217 poems and notes has been prescribed, which costs £3, and the total number of poems to be studied for the pass course is only 12?
Comment on this
I will have the Deputy's suggestion in the matter conveyed to those responsible for drawing up the curriculum in relation to this matter.
Comment on this
However, I have indicated that it is considered desirable that a book of this sort should not be confined solely to those poems or items of literature which are being included in the course but that others could be available so that comparisons can be made; indeed, so that those comparisons may be drawn on in relation to examination answers given by pupils.
Comment on this
Is the Parliamentary Secretary serious when he indicates that, if 12 poems are prescribed for the pass leaving certificate course, 12 of the simplest poems in the anthology, the anthology which must be prescribed for that course is one containing 217 poems and notes?
Comment on this
On the face of it, that does appear somewhat strange. I shall have the matter looked at.