We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Marriage Annulments.

Marriage Annulments and Civil Nullity

Summary

The Minister said Church annulments do not permit remarriage under civil law, which treats a subsequent marriage as bigamous, and rejected automatic state recognition of any one Church’s rulings. The Government is reviewing civil nullity law, including its grounds, while considering the issue in a pluralist society; the Minister said the review would examine relevant Church grounds and that bigamous unions should be discouraged.

andDr. Loughnane asked the Minister for Justice if he is aware of the large number of annulments now being granted by the Catholic Church; and if, in view of the legal position that arises from these annulments, he will make a statement on the matter.

Comment on this

I am aware that in the past year or so there has been an increase in annulments granted by the religious tribunals of the Roman Catholic Church. Persons who obtain such annulments are not, of course, free to remarry unless they obtain an annulment in the civil courts. The civil law relating to nullity is at present being examined.

Comment on this

Are these people not entitled to get married again under Church laws?

Comment on this

Yes, if people get an annulment from the Church, then in the eyes of the Church they are no longer married; there never was a marriage. What happens within the Church is a matter between the people concerned and the Church. They are not free to marry again civilly, unless they obtain an annulment in the civil courts.

Comment on this

Most people understand that Church law is State law. Arising from that, if an annulment by the Church is allowed, they are then free to marry again and are married with the blessing of the Church. Complications can set in when a person dies who has had no children by the first marriage but had children by the second marriage because under the 1966 Succession Act his first wife, with whom he never lived, would be entitled to two-thirds of his estate.

Comment on this

There would be very few people who would be so misled as to think that if they obtained a Church annulment they were free to marry again. They would know the consequences of their actions. It would be a bigamous marriage under the civil law if they were to marry again.

Comment on this

In view of the fact that the number of annulments is rising—I understand that there has been a drastic increase in annulments this year—does the Minister see any need to legislate in this regard?

Comment on this

As I indicated in my reply, I am aware that there has been an increase in the number of annulments granted by the religious tribunal of the Roman Catholic Church. I then said that the civil law relating to nullity is being reviewed.

Comment on this

The Minister no doubt is aware that even with annulment by the Catholic Church if the people concerned marry again they are marrying bigamously in the eyes of the State. I read some time ago that the Minister for Health said the Government intend to recognise annulment of marriage by the Catholic Church.

Comment on this

The Government could not be put in the position of having to recognise annulment granted by a specific Church. The Government is the Government for all the people, of all religions. The question of annulment raises serious matters of concern to a growing number of citizens, as Deputy Davern indicated. Because of the growing size of the problem, it is being examined by the Government with a view to seeing if the plight of these people can be eased.

Comment on this

In view of the fact that the Church marriage is regarded by the State as a contract of marriage, and in the light of an annulment of that contract by the Church authorities because the contract did not have the necessary ingredients to maintain it, will the Minister comment on the view that the contract is no longer even a civil contract?

Comment on this

The people adjudicating on that contract would be the Church authorities, not the State. In the eyes of the Church authorities there never was a valid contract and to that extent, in the view of the Church an annulment is granted. It does not necessarily follow that the State will take the same view, nor does it follow from what the Deputy says that because the Church is the registrar for the State in these cases, the State should apply Church law.

Comment on this

Would the Minister accept that the grounds for State nullity are much more stringent than those which apply in the Canon Law? Can the Minister indicate if this review body which is being set up will consider extending the grounds under which civil nullity can be granted, to have it coincide with the Canon Law grounds of nullity?

Comment on this

It is quite clear that the grounds of nullity under the civil law will have to be looked at. A review without looking at those grounds and considering their aptness or otherwise, whether they should be narrowed or widened, would be pointless. The Deputy can take it that they will have to be looked at and examined. I am not saying the examination will lead to the conclusion that they should be on all fours with the grounds as found by the Church, because we live in a pluralist society.

Comment on this

I accept that this examination will have to be conducted in its own right without having regard to the canons of any church. Will the Minister indicate how this review is being carried out and how representative is the committee?

Comment on this

It is being done departmentally and there is access to any information or expert advice required to discharge the task fully and completely.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Final supplementaries from Deputy Loughnane and Deputy Davern.

Comment on this

This is a very important matter.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Yes, and the Chair has given Deputies a lot of latitude. We shall have to pass on to the next question.

Comment on this

Will the Minister in his departmental review take into account the new grounds which the Church is using for annulment not just merely on consummation grounds but on mental, maturity, and other grounds the Church is using now? Would the Minister consider this as urgent legislation?

Comment on this

I am not aware of the specific grounds which the Catholic Church will admit as a basis for annulment. I have no doubt that the body who are looking into this will inform themselves of these grounds and will take them into consideration.

Comment on this

Will the Minister agree that the annulment of marriage by the Catholic Church could be described as the Catholic method of divorce?

Comment on this

I do not agree because there is a distinct and clear difference between annulment and divorce. Annulment finds there never was a marriage; divorce finds there was a marriage and breaks a valid marriage bond.

Comment on this

Pending the review to which the Minister referred, will he state the attitude of the Government towards cases of bigamy?

Comment on this

I would deprecate that bigamous unions would take place. They should be discouraged.

Comment on this