We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Medical Cards.

Eastern Health Board medical card withdrawals

Summary

The Minister reported 31,177 cards issued to new applicants and 29,822 not renewed or withdrawn in the year to 31 March, leaving more cards overall than a year earlier. Members challenged the withdrawals, citing inflation, unemployment, hardship and stricter procedures; the Minister disputed some explanations, said eligibility was determined by chief executive officers, and noted a review of guidelines was due at month’s end.

asked the Minister for Health the number of medical cards withdrawn by the Eastern Health Board during the past 12 months.

21.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Health the number of new medical cards issued by the Eastern Health Board during the past 12 months.

Comment on this

I propose with the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, to take Questions Nos. 20 and 21 together.

I am informed by the Eastern Health Board that, in the year ended on 31st March last, 31,177 cards were issued to new applicants and, during the same period, 29,822 cards were not renewed or were withdrawn.

Comment on this

Could the Minister indicate on what basis, in general, this staggering number of 29,000 medical cards was withdrawn? What were the general reasons?

Comment on this

They exceeded the guidelines set down by the CEOs. The Deputy will recognise that there has been an increase of 1,355 so there are more cards in that area than there were this time last year.

Comment on this

I would expect that, in the normal run of things, the number of medical cards being issued would have to increase. I am concerned about the 29,000 cards which have been withdrawn. Would the Minister agree that, in the main, the reason for the withdrawal of these cards was simply inflation?

Comment on this

I would not agree.

Comment on this

The Minister would have to agree if he were honest.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants that type of language I can give it to him as well as he can give it to me.

Comment on this

The Minister knows the reason.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no need to engender heat.

Comment on this

Would the Minister agree that many of these cards which were withdrawn would subsequently have figured in the number reissued? It is my experience that when medical cards were withdrawn, on reinvestigation as a result of representations, they were reissued?

Comment on this

It is possible that that happened as it happens in every health board.

Comment on this

Would the Minister feel that the slight increase would not be in keeping with the present economic climate in the Eastern Health Board area?

Comment on this

I told the House recently that there would be a review this month.

Comment on this

The Minister said that 31,000 new cards were issued, not reissued.

Comment on this

I stated that 31,177 cards were issued to new applicants.

Comment on this

Deputy Power suggested to the Minister that of the 31,000 cards some of them might be reissues of cards which had been withdrawn. I suggest that does not comply with the Minister's answer that 31,000 cards were issued to new applicants.

Comment on this

It is possible that they were not all new. Some people may have made an application and been turned down, and may have been admitted on reinvestigation, or some whose cards were withdrawn may have been readmitted.

Comment on this

Therefore, the words "new applicants" could cover people whose cards had been withdrawn and who had reapplied.

Comment on this

That is possible, but the net effect is that there are more cards in the Eastern Health Board area than there were 12 months ago.

Comment on this

And many more unemployed.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that cards have been withdrawn from genuine cases and this has caused considerable hardship? It is very obvious that the procedures introduced in the Eastern Health Board are much more strict. They have caused considerable hardship to the people. Many of these cases should be reconsidered.

Comment on this

The Deputy is aware that it is the chief executive officer who determines eligibility for a medical card.

Comment on this

It is very obvious that the procedures have been changed.

Comment on this

I am not aware of any change.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say when the new guidelines will be issued? Would it be possible to postpone withdrawal of cards because this will involve a whole new process of application? It could cost the health board a considerable sum of money in having them reviewed.

Comment on this

The review is to take place at the end of the month.

Comment on this

In view of the staggering figure of 29,000 cards withdrawn, does the Minister now recognise that it would satisfy a greater need in the community to extend medical cards to these people rather than pursue his programme of free hospitalisation for everybody?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is widening the debate. Question No. 22.

Comment on this

In the case of public expenditure the Minister should recognise that this would better serve the public need.

Comment on this

I am serving the public need by having more cards issued than there were last year.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister would agree that the increase in the number of medical cards is due to the increase in the number of unemployed.

Comment on this

It is a factor.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister is aware that inflation is the cause of it. In the Eastern Health Board and the Western Health Board and in every health board cards are being withdrawn. There should be a stay on these withdrawals pending a substantial rise in the guidelines to keep pace with inflation.

Comment on this

I assume that there will be no withdrawal between now and the review of the guidelines.

Comment on this

It is going on all over the country.

Comment on this

I do not to know who directed it.

Comment on this

The Minister should have adopted our motion.

Comment on this

We gave him a way out.

22.

Comment on this