We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Health Services' Seminar.

Health services seminar invitations

Summary

Tunney questioned why the private hospitals and nursing homes association was excluded and who attended; Corish said numbers had to be limited, 39 bodies were invited, and the gathering was representative and successful. They disputed whether patients were adequately represented and whether the exclusion was an affront; Corish said public representatives and nurses represented patients, and confirmed that seminar information was to be published.

asked the Minister for Health why the Irish Private Hospitals' and Nursing Homes' Association were not invited to send a representative to the Waterford seminar on health services.

25.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Health if he will state who was invited to the Waterford seminar on health services.

Comment on this

I propose, with the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, to reply to Questions Nos. 24 and 25 together. I also propose, with the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, to circulate with the Official Report a tabular statement listing the 39 bodies who were invited to send representatives to the seminar.

In organising the seminar I had of necessity to keep the numbers attending to manageable size. As I said in my closing address to the seminar I would have liked to have had even broader representation present. A number of bodies including the Irish Private Hospitals' and Nursing Homes' Association asked me after I had issued invitations if they could send representatives. I am grateful to these bodies for the interest they have shown in the seminar but unfortunately I could not agree to broaden the scope of representation beyond those bodies which are listed in the tabular statement.

Following is the Statement:

HEALTH Services' Seminar, Waterford 15-17 May, 1975.

List of bodies who were invited to send representatives.

Department of Health

Department of Social Welfare

Department of Finance

Department of the Public Service

Eastern Health Board

Midland Health Board

Mid-Western Health Board

North Eastern Health Board

North Western Health Board

South Eastern Health Board

Southern Health Board

Western Health Board

National Health Council

Comhairle na nOspidéal

Council for Postgraduate Medical and Dental Education and Training

National Social Service Council

Medico-Social Research Board

Medical Research Council of Ireland

Voluntary Health Insurance Board

National Association for the Mentally Handicapped of Ireland

Institute of Public Administration

James Connolly Memorial Hospital, Dublin

St. Laurence's Hospital, Dublin

Jervis Street Hospital

St. Vincent's Hospital, Elm Park

St. James's Hospital, Dublin

Mater Hospital, Dublin

Federated Dublin Voluntary Hospitals

North Charitable Infirmary, Cork

South Charitable Infirmary, Cork

Mercy Hospital, Cork

Irish Congress of Trade Unions

Irish Medical Association

Society of Medical Officers of Health

Medical Union

Irish Dental Association

Irish Nurses' Organisation

Pharmaceutical Society of Ireland

Royal College of Psychiatrists

Comment on this

Would the Minister accept that there is no reason why these bodies should have been excluded, no reason why private hospitals should have been excluded, or is the Minister not prepared to acknowledge the contribution they are making to the present position?

Comment on this

I am, of course, but many other bodies were not included. I tried to make the seminar as broad as possible. I admitted to the House that it was in the nature of an experiment and it proved very successful. If it had been otherwise, we would have had different comments from the House.

Comment on this

Has the Minister done anything to make amends for what we accept for the moment as the unintentional affront offered to the private hospitals?

Comment on this

I do not consider that it was an affront.

Comment on this

If they do, would the Minister accept their word? Obviously they do.

Comment on this

Very many organisations wanted to be included but it was not possible to invite them all. I invited what I thought was a representative gathering of all the professions.

Comment on this

Who did the Minister invite to represent the actual patient? I am not concerned about the professions.

Comment on this

Yes, that did concern me. The public representatives were there to represent the patients.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that the public representatives present were in a position, having regard to the medical politics which operated, fully to represent the position of the unfortunate—shall we say—patient?

Comment on this

The unfortunate patient, as the Deputy terms him, was represented fully in my view by representatives of the various political parties and by independent members of county councils and health boards.

Comment on this

The report did not show that. I saw where the professions were represented but I did not see any report that would convince me that there was anybody present whose sole concern would be for the patients.

Comment on this

Surely the nurses would be concerned about patients and they were invited.

Comment on this

It might be natural that they would be interested in representing their own position.

Comment on this

No. I do not believe that anybody there was trying to push his own interest. It was for the good of the health services that they were there and their deliberations proved that.

Comment on this

Without meaning to encourage a post mortem may I ask the Minister if in future he would not be led or misled by the dictates of his officials into having a rigid system of having a list of people who can be invited? To make some amends for this, would he ensure that the proceedings of this seminar are published and made available to every Deputy? We are the people who vote the money. We should have a say in what is happening and we should make decisions on the basis of that seminar. Would the Minister ensure that we get a copy of the report which he says he proposes to have published?

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy was absent but I did already announce on one occasion that it was intended to publish this information. I am the person responsible for the selection.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The remaining questions will appear on tomorrow's Order Paper.

Comment on this