We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Social Welfare Benefits.

Credited contributions for Laois claimant

Summary

The claimant was denied credited contributions through 10 December 1974 because officials found he was self-employed, a decision upheld on appeal; credits were allowed after his self-employment was accepted as having ceased. The Minister says he cannot reopen the earlier period without fresh evidence, but invites the Deputy to provide grounds for doing so.

asked the Minister for Social Welfare why his Department recognises for credited contributions medical certificates submitted since 11th December, 1974, by a person in County Laois (details supplied) when he was not credited for certificates of incapacity from April, 1973, onwards when he was equally medically incapable.

Comment on this

Credited contributions were not awarded to the person referred to by the Deputy in respect of medical certificates covering the period from April, 1973 to 10th December, 1974 as it was found on investigation that he was self-employed during that period to the extent that he could not be regarded as incapable of work. This decision was upheld on appeal. For the purpose of allowing credited contributions from 11th December, 1974 his self-employment was accepted as having ceased.

Comment on this

Could the Parliamentary Secretary give me any idea how this claimant can be genuinely considered to be incapable of work from 11th December when his medical condition was exactly the same as it had been from April, 1973 to that date? In view of the fact that it would appear that the deciding officer's decision has been overridden departmentally, could he not decide to extend that disqualification of the deciding officer's decision retrospectively to April, 1973 in order to meet the requirements of this case?

Comment on this

As the Deputy is aware, this case has been the subject of a decision by a deciding officer and, on appeal, by an appeals officer. These officers are independent of ministerial direction or control, as I am sure the Deputy will agree is the proper position for them to be in, and without additional or fresh evidence it is not possible for me to intervene in the case.

Comment on this

I appreciate what the Parliamentary Secretary says but is the Parliamentary Secretary not aware that on 7th March of this year I received a letter from his Department saying that the appeals officer had decided that the claimant was not entitled and that it was subsequent to that date that a further decision was taken which determined that certificates submitted from 11th December were allowable? I agree with the decision which was made subsequent to the appeals officer's decision. What I am asking the Parliamentary Secretary is, could that 11th December date be altered to April, 1973?

Comment on this

The only thing that was decided was that from 11th December he would be given credits but the decision of both the deciding officer and the appeals officer was that up to and including 10th December the man was, in fact, self-employed. I understand he ran a garage business.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary's understanding is wrong.

Comment on this

The information before me here is that the case was resubmitted to the appeals officer on 19th May, 1975 and the appeals officer in upholding his original decision pointed out that the appeals decision related to the period up to 10th December, 1974.

Comment on this

I welcome the final decision, but could it not be made retrospective?

Comment on this

If the Deputy can give me any reason to justify asking that the matter be reopened I shall gladly do so.

10.

Comment on this