Farm Modernisation Scheme allegations and eligibility
Leonard asks about claims of abuse; Clinton says the article itself contained no real criticism and that its headline was misleading. Callanan challenges the scheme’s reach and the priority given to qualifying farmers and six-year plans; both he and Clinton say they want the scheme changed.
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if his attention has been drawn to a statement (details supplied) that farmers are abusing the farm modernisation scheme; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Comment on this
I have seen reports of the statement referred to. It would seem that the main tenor of the statement was to confirm the importance of planned development of farms which is, of course, a fundamental aim of the farm modernisation scheme. The statement also emphasised the value of the scheme not only to farmers but also to advisers in bringing them into contact with many more farmers and giving them the opportunity to work more closely with them. The statement did suggest that too many farmers tended to regard the scheme as a somewhat cumbersome means of getting grants and failed to appreciate the importance of proper planning. This is a criticism which, I am confident, will quickly disappear as farmers get more experience of the scheme.
Comment on this
That has not been suggested. The headings that appeared were not justified by what was contained in the article, as often happens.
Comment on this
No, I am saying that headings can often be very misleading. When one reads the article one gets a different impression altogether.
Comment on this
Completely. These headings are intended to attract attention. There is no real criticism in the article.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying that this scheme is meant to bring advisers to more farmers? I cannot understand how he can say that when so few farmers will qualify. This will take the advisers away from the majority of farmers.
Comment on this
When advisers examine and decide into what category a farmer comes, that brings him in contact. If he is following a six-year programme, that puts a responsibility on the farmer and the adviser, who are planning the operation. This is what we all want.
Comment on this
But who will be planning that six-year programme, because few will qualify? The advisers will go in to classify a farm but his priority is the man who qualifies for the six-year programme.
Comment on this
Who is the Deputy holding responsible for this direction? I said before that neither I nor my predecessor could be responsible for a scheme that was there before we joined.