We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Dairying Industry.

Dairy surpluses and market outlook

Summary

Dr. Gibbons asked how excess dairy supplies and weak commercial demand would affect Irish dairying. Minister Clinton said the trend was unwelcome but likely temporary, cautioned against discouraging farmers, and said the EEC was developing expertise to study consumption. He said no proposal to limit skim-milk-powder intervention had been presented, while Ireland would resist making farmers responsible for surpluses.

asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if his attention has been drawn to the report of the UNFAO in which it is stated that dairy product supplies are increasingly exceeding commercial demand; and if he will indicate how this situation is likely to affect the dairying industry in this country.

Comment on this

The commercial demand for milk and milk products for human and animal consumption has been adversely affected by the world trade recession, by higher prices on domestic markets and in some cases by a lower cost of competing foods and feedingstuffs. This is particularly so in the case of individual products such as skim milk powder and to a certain extent, cheese.

Naturally, this is an unwelcome trend in so far as milk exporting countries are concerned. Nevertheless, I am convinced that the situation is a temporary one which will rectify itself within a relatively short space of time. I am confident that, in the meantime, the excellence of our own dairy products and of the arrangements which exist for marketing them will stand us in good stead and will necessitate our having only minimal recourse to sales into intervention.

Comment on this

Is the Minister prepared to say what would be a reasonable time? Will it be two or three years?

Comment on this

I would hope that it would not be anything like that.

Comment on this

Does not the report say this year or next year?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That would mean at least two years?

Comment on this

Yes, What are we trying to do? Are we trying to encourage or discourage people by saying we will have a mountain of everything? We have to get people to believe there is a future in farming. If we say we will have a milk powder mountain, a butter mountain, a cheese mountain, people will be afraid to do anything. Since we joined the EEC I saw a milk powder mountain, but it vanished. At one stage we had not enough for food aid after great complaints in the EEC about a milk powder mountain.

Comment on this

There are 500,000 tons there now.

Comment on this

There were 350,000 tons at one stage and they disappeared like that.

Comment on this

In answer to the Minister's question to me, I would be glad if we could do this. We should try to avoid a situation in which farmers' products would have to be disposed of at a cheap price. I put down the question so that this information would be available to the farming community.

Comment on this

I do not misunderstand the Deputy's motive in putting down the question.

Comment on this

It is in conflict with a previous question.

Comment on this

There is always the danger in putting down these questions that we may discourage people when they should be encouraged.

Comment on this

Does the Minister's reply indicate that a proper survey is not being carried out on consumption trends within the EEC? Is any attempt being made in the Common Market to study consumption trends?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It does not seem to have borne fruit.

Comment on this

The EEC were short of this type of expertise. They are building it up now.

Comment on this

Does the Minister anticipate any limitations in the operation of intervention for skim powder this year?

Comment on this

As Deputy Gibbons knows, there is pressure all the time from the Commission to hold farmers responsible for their own surpluses.

Comment on this

Co-responsibility.

Comment on this

It is described as co-responsibility. We have to resist it for as long as we can.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say whether in his opinion intervention will be limited for skim powder this year?

Comment on this

No such statement or recommendation or proposal has been put before us so far. That is all I can say.

Comment on this