Access to EEC agricultural statistics
The Minister said the European Communities’ statistical office publishes agricultural data and that departmental copies are available in the Library, while undertaking to provide reasonable information in answers to questions. Dr. Gibbons pressed for wider access through Question Time and challenged the precedent limiting questions on statistics; Mr. Callanan disputed whether consumption figures were yet sufficiently compiled, and the Minister said the information was available but sometimes technical.
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if agricultural statistics relating to the EEC, such as production, consumption, import and export figures, are available to him and his Department; and, if so, the circumstances under which and the manner in which he acquires them.
Comment on this
Comprehensive agricultural statistics of the kind referred to by the Deputy relating to member States and to the Community as a whole are published periodically by the statistical office of the European Communities in Luxembourg. Copies of these publications are acquired regularly by my Department in the normal way.
Comment on this
Will the Minister and his Department make this information available to Deputies if they write to the Department, or at Question Time in this House?
Comment on this
Whatever information there is is in the Library. Most of these publications are available in the Library.
Comment on this
The usual thing for a Minister to say is that the Deputy can get the information in the Library.
Comment on this
Will the Minister make this information available to Deputies in the House if they put down questions?
Comment on this
It might not be possible, without giving answers a mile long on some of these matters, to give the information a Deputy might be seeking.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree—in view of what has been said already in reply to other questions and in view also of the supplementary question Deputy Callanan posed, that it is a very important function of the Minister in the House to make information available.
Comment on this
The Minister will agree, it is probably through Question Time and looking up reports that many organisations get this detailed information and that it is a much more important exercise than the Minister seems to appreciate at present?
Comment on this
I am not criticising the Ceann Comhairle. I find I get the greatest co-operation from him.
Comment on this
Of course, the Minister does. Is the Minister aware that the Ceann Comhairle has refused to allow questions of mine to the Minister —for statistical information—on the basis that the Minister has no responsibility therefor?
Comment on this
I am quite sure that what the Ceann Comhairle is doing is following precedent over the years in the Chair.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree it is time to change this precedent now that we are in the EEC?
Comment on this
With regard to the question posed by Deputy Dr. Gibbons about information, is there a lot of this information available yet, or are they merely commencing to compile such information?
Comment on this
No, it is available; it is in the Library but some of it is of a very technical nature and quite difficult to follow.
Comment on this
As far as consumption is concerned, I doubt if there is much information available. I am claiming that in Brussels not sufficient of this has been done. That is the question I put to the Minister a short while ago and he agreed with me that they are only commencing to do so.