We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Erne Fishery Closure.

Erne salmon pass suitability

Summary

Blaney asked whether the fish pass was suitable for salmon moving upstream; Murphy said departmental advisers considered it appropriate. Brennan argued that other schemes used a more efficient design and urged a second opinion, while Murphy defended his advisers’ assessment.

Recently I asked the Parliamentary Secretary if he was satisfied that the type of pass was the most suitable to permit the salmon to go from the lower river through the tailrace to the upper reaches and he undertook to have the position examined. Has he got any information since?

Comment on this

I asked my advisers, and they claim that the system is quite in order. That is the information available to me and, as the Deputy will appreciate, I must accept the advice of those competent to advise.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is aware that in other hydroelectric schemes, such as Poulaphouca, the pass is different and seems to be more efficient.

Comment on this

The particular pass referred to here is deemed to be the most suitable. That is the advice given to me, and I am not competent to go against that advice and neither am I competent to evaluate the situation.

Comment on this

Buy a second opinion.

Comment on this

The Deputy's opinion is against the opinion of those well qualified in this particular field of actvity.

Comment on this

The pass does not work.

Comment on this