We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Telephone Service.

Rural telephone kiosks at Monteen Cross and Muckalee

Summary

The Minister said kiosks are not normally provided in rural areas without post offices, except under a guarantee scheme, but he is reviewing the rules. Gibbons argued that the populated areas need public telephones and questioned whether urban areas receive priority; the Minister denied discrimination and invited evidence.

asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs if he will arrange to have a telephone kiosk provided at Monteen Cross, Bilboa, Crettyard, Carlow, County Kilkenny.

6.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs if he will arrange to have a telephone kiosk provided at Muckalee, Ballyfoyle, County Kilkenny.

Comment on this
Conor Cruise-O'Brien Minister for Posts and Telegraphs (Dr. Cruise-O'Brien) Labour Party

I propose with the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, to take Questions Nos. 5 and 6 together.

Kiosks are not being provided in rural areas such as Monteen Cross and Muckalee where there are no post offices.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that, while both those areas can be described as rural areas, they are both very heavily populated and, in the case of Mooneenroe, there are two factories in the district and several hundred households and they have no access to telephonic communications other than the provision of a public telephone?

Comment on this

I appreciate the Deputy's concern. Under existing regulations and practice, as they have been in force for many years, it is not possible for the State to provide a kiosk in such an area without a post office, except under the guarantee system from a local authority or other such body, of which I think the Deputy is aware. I am not fully happy about the existing regulations and practice about the provision of kiosks in rural areas. I have the question under study at the moment of whether certain changes can be made in this practice leading to economies in the public service and, I would hope also, to greater possibility of satisfaction for the people in rural areas.

Comment on this

Is the Minister conscious of the fact that the apparent discrimination against people resident in rural areas is a matter of some concern to those people, and will he remove this cause of irritation in any subsequent review of the regulations?

Comment on this

I am not aware of any discrimination against rural areas in this matter. If the Deputy gave me any evidence of that I would certainly look into it with care. My Department are anxious to be fair both to people in rural areas and, of course, to those urban areas where, in rapidly expanding suburbs, the provision of kiosks is a matter of concern and also, of course, a costly matter because of the vandalism question. I am looking very carefully at the whole thing and I am very anxious to consider representations from Deputies. If they can show me they have reason to believe the rural areas are discriminated against in any way in this area, I will certainly check it.

Comment on this

It is inherent in what the Minister said that the necessity for the provision of telephone services in newly built-up urban areas seems to take some precedence over areas which are not urban areas.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

The Minister asked for evidence.

Comment on this

As Minister, I have to take note of the fact, which affects the postal services as every other service, of movements of population. Primarily we are here to render services to people wherever the people are, whether they are in built-up urban areas or in rural areas, but to people. If there are a lot of people in one place in, say, a Dublin suburb, I do not apologise for giving those people equal consideration with people in rural areas. I do not regard that as discrimination. I do not think the Deputy would suggest it is.

7.

Comment on this