Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Pay-Related Benefit.
- Pay-related benefit calculation basis 10 speeches
Nolan argued that calculating benefit from the previous tax year can exclude people whose recent employment or illness makes that figure unrepresentative. Cluskey defended the existing basis, saying the proposed alternative would not improve the scheme.
Thomas Nolan, Frank Cluskey, Seán Treacy
- Pay-related benefit fund balance 7 speeches
Haughey asked about the Fund’s balance; Cluskey said it was healthy but could not give a figure. Nolan suggested the balance reflected people not receiving the benefit.
Charles J. Haughey, Frank Cluskey, Seán Treacy, Thomas Nolan
asked the Minister for Social Welfare if he will consider paying pay-related benefit on the average weekly earnings of an applicant during his period of employment rather than on the average annual weekly earnings.
Comment on this
The basis on which pay-related benefit is calculated was carefully considered when the scheme was being drawn up and the system introduced, which takes account of an applicant's earnings over the income tax year, was considered to be the most equitable and suitable arrangement. While I am always ready to consider improvements in the scheme of pay-related benefit I am not satisfied that the arrangement suggested by the Deputy would improve the scheme.
Comment on this
Surely the Parliamentary Secretary is aware that, when Fianna Fáil introduced the scheme of pay-related benefits, the idea behind it was to cushion an employee who, possibly, had hire-purchase commitments, an SDA loan or other financial commitments, but because it is based now on the previous financial year, many a person unemployed today does not qualify for any pay-related benefit whatsoever? He may have been unemployed for part of the year 1973-74; came into employment again early in 1975, finds himself again unemployed and does not qualify for pay-related benefit? If the idea behind the scheme was to cushion an employee against lack of earnings because of either sickness or unemployment, I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary—as mentioned in my question—that the pay-related benefit be based on the average earnings of the three months prior to a person becoming unemployed.
Comment on this
Several improvements were made by way of regulation under the scheme drawn up by the former Administration, all of which were to the benefit of the recipients. Pay-related benefit is designed to ensure, as far as possible, that a man's normal earnings be maintained, to some extent, during periods of prolonged sickness or unemployment. The operation of the scheme has proved to be of very considerable value to people who avail of it. I do not think that the proposal made by the Deputy would achieve the object of the scheme.
Comment on this
Surely the Parliamentary Secretary will agree that if a person was sick for, say, six months of 1973-74—because it is only on his income tax return to the Revenue Commissioners that pay-related benefit is based—even if his social welfare payments when he was ill in 1973-74 were added to his earnings it would be of some help? But, at present, as the Parliamentary Secretary is well aware——
Comment on this
——the pay-related benefit scheme is not helping those it was intended to help in so far as cushioning their problem when unemployed or sick?
Comment on this
Irrespective of what period one might choose on which to make a judgment, some people would benefit by a particular period and some would lose. Since the introduction of the pay-related benefit scheme, fortunately persons who find themselves in the position the Deputy has described benefit very considerably.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary confirm that there is a very substantial balance in the Fund at present?
Comment on this
Could the Parliamentary Secretary indicate approximately what is the balance at present?