Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Cattle Industry.
- Irish cattle reference prices and variable premiums 11 speeches
The Minister attributed Ireland’s low cattle reference price to export, transport and marketing costs, while Deputy Gibbons argued that Irish farmers lacked the variable-premium advantages available to UK farmers. They disputed whether Irish producers receive the same premium, with the Minister also citing a 6 per cent export subsidy.
James M. Gibbons, Mark A. Clinton
- Prospects for Irish cattle producers 8 speeches
The Minister acknowledged growing UK beef production and monetary compensatory charges but remained optimistic about long-term prospects, citing an EEC forecast of a small 1980 export surplus and improved competitiveness for continental sales. Deputy Gibbons urged stronger promotion on the Continent, while Deputy Meaney questioned the reliability of the forecasts.
James M. Gibbons, Mark A. Clinton, Thomas J. V. Meaney
andMr. Fahey asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if he will explain why the reference price for Irish cattle is consistently the lowest in the European Community and in particular why this is so in relation to the UK price (excluding the Six Counties), where a separate and lower variable premium has been introduced.
Comment on this
Unlike other Community countries, over four-fifths of Ireland's production of beef has to be exported in one form or another. This involves substantial transport and marketing costs which are reflected in a lower market price here.
I might, indeed, say that the difference between the Irish and UK prices is somewhat greater than is indicated by the reference prices as the quoted UK figure does not include the slaughter and variable premia.
The level of price for cattle here is, of course, one of the matters being looked into by the review body on intervention. An interim report has recently been furnished by that body and is at present being examined by my Department.
Comment on this
Is the Minister not aware that reference prices in the United Kingdom and in Ireland tend to be much lower than on the Continent? In England, Wales and Scotland the United Kingdom farmers have the advantage of the variable premium payment which makes up the difference between the actual market price and the level to which it would need to be compensated in order to bring it to the guide price but farmers here and in the North of Ireland have no such advantage. In the case of the variable premium for the North of Ireland and for the south, the British Government have recently made changes that have been to our detriment.
Comment on this
I wonder if it is to our detriment that it is somewhat higher in the North of Ireland?
Comment on this
The Minister misunderstands me. If he looks at the most recent arrangements made by the United Kingdom Government he will see that the farmers in the North of Ireland have had some of the advantages of the variable premium taken from them while their colleagues in the rest of the United Kingdom still have the benefit of them.
Comment on this
The Deputy must not lose sight of the fact that our cattle going into the United Kingdom get a subsidy of 6 per cent——
Comment on this
The Minister should not attempt to obscure the question by bringing in the export refund that arises from the different devaluation of the green £ that operates in the United Kingdom and the south of Ireland. I am talking about the difference in the level of the variable premium that has been introduced by the United Kingdom for the whole of Ireland.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if, in view of (a) the rapid strides being made in Great Britain towards greater self-sufficiency in beef and the consequent likelihood of a smaller market there for Irish cattle and beef and (b) the increasing monetary taxes on Irish beef and cattle going to the Continent, he will indicate the prospects for Irish cattle producers.
Comment on this
I am fully aware of the trend towards increased beef production in the United Kingdom and of the problems which monetary compensatory amounts create for our cattle and beef industry. I am, nevertheless, convinced that the long-term prospects for our cattle producers are good. A recent study forecasts that the EEC will in 1980 have an export surplus of only 29,000 metric tons of beef despite an increase over 1975 estimated production of 385,000 metric tons, including an extra 60,000 tons in Ireland.
I have repeatedly sought to have the disadvantages of the MCA system for this country eased and my efforts have met with success.
Comment on this
Will the Minister not agree that the Irish beef industry will need to look more closely at continental markets and sell more actively? Would it not be better for the Government to induce the Irish fresh meat industry to sell on the Continent and, if necessary, to spend some of the enormous profits made last year rather than have that industry taxed in order to subsidise the cost of living for the benefit of other members of the community? Would it not be better to invest their earnings in a sales campaign on the Continent?
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy on the need for a greater effort to sell on the Continent but the prospects now are much better since we got the devaluation in the representative rate of the Irish pound and because of the improvement in sterling. We are now in a much better position to compete on the Continent and I hope our people will take advantage of that.
Comment on this
What confidence does the Minister place in those forecasts seeing that they were proved so wrong last year? Forecasts have been notoriously wrong and to be speaking about 1980 will not give any confidence to the farmers.