Calf prices and suckler herds
Gibbons linked collapsing calf prices to the decline in beef-suckler herds and challenged the Minister’s reliance on scheme applications. Clinton disputed the link and cited a review of how intervention and slaughter-premium benefits could be distributed; Callanan argued calf producers remained neglected.
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if he is aware that the virtual elimination of beef-suckler herds has caused a disastrous drop in the price of calves; and the steps he proposes to take to restore the position which obtained before 1973.
Comment on this
I do not accept the connection which the Deputy makes between the present prices for calves and what he asserts to be the virtual elimination of beef-suckler herds. The latter assertion is in any event not borne out by figures for applications under the beef cattle incentive scheme.
I am fully aware of the price problems relating to calves and young cattle. It is my aim to secure equitable distribution of the benefits of the intervention and slaughter premium systems amongst all producers of cattle and I have set up a review body to advise me on how this might be done. Already that body has submitted an interim report to me which I am having examined.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that the problems I referred to in my question will not go away by the incantation of pious platitudes? I base my assertion on the fact that cow slaughterings last year were more than three times the normal annual slaughterings and the undeniable fact that calf prices have dropped to nothing. Does the Minister not agree that it is a reasonable assumption that the purchasers of calves who maintained the price of calves up to now were the beef-suckler herd owners?
Comment on this
I am told that it is not so and that it is not borne out by the applications for the cattle incentive scheme.
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell the House when the producers of calves will know that the benefits which may be gained from these schemes, intervention or otherwise, will be passed on to them? It is that farmer who has no confidence in the future.