Revocation of promotion regulations amendment
Dowling challenged the revocation of amendment 83 and questioned the legality of promotions and the treatment of officers passed over. Donegan maintained that the promotions were legal and said he cited additional provisions to remove any possibility of costly litigation.
asked the Minister for Defence why he revoked amendment 83 of the Defence Force Regulations A15 made by him on 17th June, 1975; and the nature and degree of the deficiencies in the amendment which led to its revocation.
Comment on this
During the debate on the Deputy's motion in Private Members' Time on the 8th and 9th July, 1975, the Deputy made the case that section 45 of the Defence Act, 1954, had been wrongly cited as the authority for amendment No. 83 to Defence Force Regulations A. 15. In the light of the debate I examined the position, as I was requested to do during the debate, and I concluded that I had two options, namely
(a) retain amendment No. 83 and leave the initiative regarding litigation—the possibility of which the Deputy had projected during the debate—to any person wishing to engage in such litigation.
or
(b) make a new regulation.
Rather than put anybody to the expense of litigation I chose course (b) and made amendment No. 84, the citation in which includes both section 26 and section 45 of the Act.
As the Deputy was informed by letter dated 18th August, 1975, from my Department, three other regulations which had been made in the period 1964-1970 were revoked and remade, in addition to amendment No. 83, in the form of amendment No. 84.
Comment on this
Arising out of the reply and the illegal promotions which were rectified while the House was adjourned, may I ask the Minister if during the debate he indicated on two occasions that he had checked with the Attorney General's Office and that the Attorney General had indicated that the Minister's action was in order? Would the Minister now indicate to the House that he was misled by both the Attorney General and the legal staff of the Department of Defence?
Comment on this
The promotions were legal and are legal and I am so advised at this moment in time by the Attorney General. I was advised at all times that such promotions were legal but so that there would be no question or quibble or somebody invoking litigation which might be very expensive for himself and very unpleasant for persons with families who might be observing a person promoted, whose promotion at that point was almost sub judice, I decided, to put things absolutely beyond doubt because of the allegations of Deputy Dowling, that I would cite other sections and I so cited. I would remind the House that I cited also section 45 and I am advised at this point by the Attorney General that section 45 was legal, was legal during the period of adjournment of the Dáil and is legal. But I cited the other sections to make sure that there was no danger of anybody resorting to litigation which would only impose expense on themselves. The Deputy was so informed by the Secretary of my Department in a letter dated 18th August, 1975. He waited for a week and then gave this letter to The Sunday Press.
Comment on this
The Minister says: "...to put the matter beyond all doubt" so the Minister had a doubt in his mind and the Minister is still not up to date on this matter in so far as the promotions were illegal. I should now like to know what action he proposes to take in relation to the officers who were at that time recommended by the Chief of Staff and who were passed over by the Minister and not promoted? Does he propose to take any action now to ensure that the careers of these men will be protected and that their rights in the future will be adequately safeguarded?
Comment on this
I am not responsible for statements made by the Deputy. In fact some statements made at the present moment are in my view quite erroneous. I want to assure the House that my advice from the Attorney General's Office is that section 45 was the relevant section at all times and remains the relevant section but so as to remove all doubt and so as to make these promotions absolutely beyond doubt, even doubt expressed by the Deputy which did not help the morale of the Defence Forces or the work that had to be done within the Defence Forces, I cited—and here is the very important punch line—not only other sections but section 45. I cited those sections. That means those promotions stand, were legal and are legal.
Comment on this
The Chair wants to avoid overlapping. There are a number of questions related to this subject matter. We cannot delay unduly on any one of them.
Comment on this
This is a very important issue; it is the breaking of the law by the Minister. I want to point out to the Minister that he made the orders under the wrong section. He is entitled to make promotions under section 45 but he is not entitled to change regulations under that section.
Comment on this
The Minister has now rectified the situation and I would like to ask him if he now regards the "barrack room lawyers"— by which description he referred to those who advised me—as inferior to the Attorney General who has now mended his hand?