Exchange losses on external loans
The Minister said exchange losses on external loans already redeemed totalled £7.5 million, but said future losses could not be reliably forecast. He could not provide the loan dates or a comparable estimate for State borrowing; follow-ups asked about upcoming redemptions and whether the Government should heed his advice to the Agricultural Credit Corporation.
asked the Minister for Finance the extent to which the State has lost money because of the fact that borrowed money has now appreciated in value against the pound sterling.
Comment on this
Exchange losses incurred on external loans redeemed to date amount to £7½ million. As it is not possible to forecast what exchange rates may be when other loans become due for redemption, no reliable estimate can be given as to whether gains or losses or either may be incurred at times of redemption.
Comment on this
May we take it that that is what is involved, from the first loan obtained by the State, which involved a loss of money by reason of a change in currency exchange rates? Is that what the Minister is covering in the reply, from the beginning up to date?
Comment on this
On any foreign loans that have been redeemed. But I have not got the dates upon which the loans——
Comment on this
I do not think that is what the question asked. Surely it asks the extent to which there has been a loss in respect of money borrowed whether redeemed or not?
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate that one cannot say with certainty what may be the fluctuations in the market. It is not, therefore, possible at this stage to say what losses may be created as a consequence of exchange movements. The mere fact that there could be losses today—if the loan was repaid today—is no certainty that a loss of a similar kind or that any loss would occur on the date that a loan would be repaid.
Comment on this
No doubt the Minister is familiar with the losses sustained by the Agricultural Credit Corporation by reason of exchange rate fluctuations. In fact, he referred to it recently in a statement to that body. Could he give a figure arrived at on a comparable basis in respect of State borrowing?
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): Could the Minister give any indication whether loans are to be redeemed very shortly or are any loans to be redeemed during 1976?
Comment on this
Could the Minister give the same advice to the Government in the matter as he gave to the ACC?