Extending the transport subsidy
Faulkner asked that the subsidy cover rail commuters from Drogheda and Dundalk, but Ryan said the scheme would not be extended. Colley also challenged the exclusion of private operators on shared routes; Ryan cited administrative costs. The sitting ended with a procedural exchange about raising Question 33 on the Adjournment.
asked the Minister for Finance if he will extend the transport subsidy granted in the June, 1975 budget to cover commuters from Drogheda and Dundalk and intermediate stations to Dublin, in view of the anomaly of the present position.
Comment on this
The new transport subsidy announced in my financial statement of 26th June was provided to enable CIE to reduce the fares they charge on Dublin city bus services, road passenger provincial services and Dublin and Cork commuter rail services to the levels which obtained before 12th May, 1975.
Having regard to the limited amount of public money that was available for the purpose the services chosen to receive the benefit of the new transport subsidy were the widest-ranging possible in the circumstances, and it is not intended to extend the scope of the subsidy.
Comment on this
I know of at least one case in which CIE buses running on part of exactly the same route as privately operated public transport are getting the benefit of the subsidy whereas the privately operated transport is not. Therefore, the customers of the privately operated transport are not getting it on the same routes. Does the Minister really think that this can be justified on grounds of alleged easier administration? Surely this is not an insuperable problem of administration?
Comment on this
There are considerable problems of administration and of increasing the measure. We chose the method which gave the widest possible benefit with the least possible administrative costs and complexity.
Comment on this
In view of the unsatisfactory reply to Question No. 33 I wish, with your permission, to have the matter raised on the Adjournment.