Tipperary rates
A dispute over rising county rates began when Fitzgerald asked whether the Minister was concerned; Tully claimed rates had been reduced by more than £2 in the £ and said they would otherwise be higher. Opposition members challenged the claim and cited the former policy of removing rates from dwelling houses. The exchange became heated, and the Chair repeatedly ruled on relevance and disorderly accusations before Lalor apologised to the Chair.
Since the Minister is so liberal with his answers today perhaps he would indicate whether he is concerned with the huge increase in the rates in Tipperary as well as in every other county compared with what was the situation during the term of office of his predecessor?
Comment on this
I have shown such concern that the rates in Tipperary have been reduced by more than £2 in the £. In other words, had there not been a change in Government, ratepayers in Tipperary would be paying £2 in the £ more than they are paying.
Comment on this
I wonder if we might have an arrangement in this House whereby Ministers would be prevented from telling lies?
Comment on this
The Minister has stated categorically that if he were not in office the rates in Tipperary would be £2 in the £ more than they are.
Comment on this
Is the Minister not aware that we had decided to remove rates entirely from dwelling houses? If we were in office the unfortunate ratepayers would not be faced with the colossal demands that are being made on them.
Comment on this
In view of the record of the people opposite I never thought that I would again hear them accuse me of telling lies in this House.
Comment on this
The Minister is not in order in stating that if Fianna Fáil were in office the rates would be higher than they are.
Comment on this
Deputy Lalor states I was telling lies and he says that he will not withdraw that accusation. I want to make it very clear, since he is not man enough to do so, that as far as I am concerned I have not been found out telling lies in this House and, when Members on the opposite benches can stand up and say the same, only then may Deputy Lalor make that allegation.
Comment on this
I have already said that it is disorderly for any Member to attribute a lie to another and, if that has been done, it must be withdrawn.
Comment on this
I want to make it clear, and it can be checked on the record, that I asked the Ceann Comhairle to arrange that no Minister would tell a lie in this House. That is what I said.
Comment on this
I have given a statement of fact and it was always the practice in this House that, when a Minister made a statement of fact, it was accepted by the Opposition. If the Opposition want to make new rules now about these matters then they will have to go elsewhere, but I will not change the statement I made because it is factual.
Comment on this
I trust Deputy Lalor is not trying to get around the ruling of the Chair. A lie is a lie and nothing will ever make it lawful.
Comment on this
I accept that and I apologise to the Chair if I said categorically that anybody is a liar. What I did say was that the Minister has no right to make a statement here on the supposition that, if Fianna Fáil were in power, the rates would be £2 in the £ greater than they are at present. That is not a statement of fact.