Farm modernisation scheme review
The Minister said proposals to improve the scheme, including its suitability for western conditions, had been submitted to the EEC Commission as part of a review. Callanan and Lynch argued that the scheme was unsuitable from the outset and sought substantial changes; Murphy said it was being reviewed as expected and could not give a date for the outcome.
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries the action he proposes to take to have the farm modernisation scheme rendered more suitable and more acceptable to Irish farmers, particularly to farmers in the 12 western counties.
49.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries the action he proposes to take to have the farm modernisation scheme rendered more suitable to Irish needs and more acceptable to the farmers.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 48 and 49 together.
On the basis of experience during the first year of operation of the scheme, proposals have been made to the EEC Commission for a reappraisal of a number of aspects of Directive 159/72 on which the scheme is based. Discussions on these proposals have already been initiated with the Commission in the context of a general review of the directive which the Commission is undertaking. I would hope that the outcome of these discussions will be such as to enable us to introduce desirable improvements in the scheme and its operation.
Comment on this
I am glad the Parliamentary Secretary recognises that the scheme is completely unsuitable but I should like to know when we can expect to have the proposed changes in Directive 159? They would want to be drastic changes.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister, and the Parliamentary Secretary, now realise that when we described this scheme as being unsuitable we were not throwing a spanner in the works.
Comment on this
The scheme is in its infancy and, like all schemes, is subject to review. We have made representations to Brussels to change the scheme. It is natural that all such schemes should be reviewed and the Minister has put forward his report on the review to the Commission and the Council of Ministers.
Comment on this
Am I to take it that the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary now realise that changes are necessary?
Comment on this
The Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary realise that reviews are necessary on all schemes. What was appropriate last year may not be appropriate this year or next year. The Government carry out reviews daily.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary agree that if the scheme was properly applied to conditions, especially in the west of Ireland, in the first instance there would be no necessity for a review and that the necessity for proper application and the taking into account of conditions in the west were apparent from the start?
Comment on this
The Deputy is incorrect. The scheme was approved and then the question of review arose as a result of the representations made. The scheme was operated in line with the thinking of the EEC but time was limited because we wanted to get the scheme under way for the 1974-75 period. It was taken for granted that in the early years of its operation this scheme would be reviewed annually. Other countries have applied for a review also. There is no question of the scheme being implemented without being given full consideration.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary not agree that the scheme ab initio was totally inadequate for all purposes?
Comment on this
No. I am sure that if Deputy Lynch was in charge of the Government the scheme would not be as elaborate as it is at present and that the question of review would not arise because Fianna Fáil did not believe in review. We believe in reviews and I believe schemes of such importance should be reviewed from time to time. I have no doubt that further reviews will be made as they are required.
50.