Farm retirement eligibility for leased land
Lalor’s two Laois applicants had been refused because they were letting their farms, under rules requiring five years of at least 50% working time and income from the land. The Minister said he had secured a more flexible interpretation for farmers letting land for valid reasons, and confirmed the cases would be reconsidered and had an excellent chance of qualifying.
asked the Minister for Lands why two persons (names supplied) in County Laois are not permitted to sell their farms to the Land Commission under the EEC farm retirement scheme.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The two applications in question were very fully investigated by the Land Commission but as the applicants were leting their lands they did not at that time satisfy the requirements for eligibility. However, I will have the two cases re-examined urgently in the light of arrangements I have now made with the EEC and which I will be explaining shortly in reply to Questions Nos. 30 and 34.
Comment on this
(Cavan): It would be more appropriate because it solves the Deputy's problem in principle anyway.
Comment on this
In relation to one of those cases which, for convenience, I shall refer to as the Castletown case, is it not the position that under the existing arrangement the farmer must have devoted at least half his working time to the holding during the five years immediately prior to making the application? In the case in question is it not correct to say that the man concerned had let his land for only about six months before the order was made and the scheme introduced and that, therefore, it could be claimed that he had been working the land for four-and-a-half years in which case he would have spent more than half his time in this capacity?
Comment on this
(Cavan): In respect of one case here I notice the names and addresses of about half the Members of the Dáil. However, the Deputy may take it that up to now it was a condition precedent to the scheme applying that the applicant must have had in each of the five years devoted 50 per cent of his time and derived 50 per cent of his income from working the land which was the subject of the application. I am pleased to tell the Deputy that in reply to the next two questions I shall be indicating that this situation has been changed.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Yes, and I am told that they have an excellent chance of qualifying. Although the Deputy has become involved in this at this late stage he will probably try to claim some credit for it.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Lands the steps, if any, that are being taken to include lands rented on the 11 months system in the retirement scheme under Directive 160.
34.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Lands the date on which he asked the EEC Commission to amend the farm retirement scheme; and the terms of the amendment submitted.
Comment on this
(Cavan): With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 30 and 34 together.
The amendment which I was concerned to introduce into the farm retirement scheme was to secure a flexible interpretation of the condition in Directive 160 that an applicant must have been working his lands for the previous five years. As it stood, this condition meant that resident farmers who by reason of age, infirmity, or for any other compelling reason had to let their holdings as a temporary measure to secure a livelihood were denied the benefits of the scheme. We have made many informal approaches to the EEC Commission on this matter since the scheme was brought in. Indeed, speaking in the Seanad in April last I indicated my criticism of the fact that many applicants who were letting their lands because of ill health, financial or other valid reason but who were still living on their farms were being excluded from the scheme. I am, therefore, very pleased to be able to announce that such deserving applicants, provided they are otherwise qualified, can now be admitted to the scheme and will be eligible for the benefits of the directive.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear this. May we take it that in relation to this scheme those who are letting land will not be excluded for this reason? These are the people who will wish to retire.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Deputy may take it that anybody who has no other occupation, is living on or near his land but who is letting it because of ill-health, old age or because he is not making a go of it or for some other valid reason, will not be deprived of the benefits of the farm retirement scheme under Directive 160 solely because he is letting. In other words, if he is otherwise qualified, he will come within the terms of the scheme.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say when this decision was made? My reason for asking is that there is a need to change a number of the directives and it appears that the Minister is able to bring about such changes.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I saw this flaw in the scheme almost immediately after its coming into operation.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I have been working on it since. I cannot give the exact date of the change but within the past two weeks or so I arranged with Brussels that the liberal interpretation in regard to 50 per cent working time and 50 per cent income would get the broad interpretation I have indicated here.
31.