Encouraging private forestry
The Minister cited planting grants and free advice, but argued that small farms and long returns limit private afforestation; he favoured EEC support for State forests. Haughey urged greater ambition, including small-scale planting, and asked that Ireland’s circumstances be reflected in EEC decisions; the Minister said he would seek favourable interpretation of the directives.
asked the Minister for Lands if he has any plans for encouraging the development of forestry through private endeavour.
Comment on this
(Cavan): My Department already operate a private planting grant scheme. In addition those eligible for such grants are offered advice on planting free of charge. I also envisage the holding of a seminar designed to examine the problems of the private forestry sector.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware —I take it he is—of the EEC proposals in regard to forestry in general?
Comment on this
Arising out of this new development, has he any particular plans with regard to private forestry here?
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am sure the Deputy knows the EEC Directive provides only for assistance to private forestry.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Conditions here do not lend themselves to extensive private afforestation. By and large, farms are small. Indeed, in latter years, as the value of agricultural land increases the planting of trees becomes less attractive. I would like to see the assistance proposed by the EEC extended to State forests because the vast majority of forests are State owned.
Comment on this
I am aware that State forests predominate, but does the Minister not agree enormous good could be achieved from the point of view of the environment, conservation and so on, through the encouragement of private forests? In so far as we have not been as active in the past in regard to private forestry as we might have been would the Minister not avail of this new proposal to bring about a departure from the programme to encourage widespread private forestry?
Comment on this
(Cavan): I personally am of the opinion that, because of the size of the farms, it is not likely there will be any extensive planting of trees as most farmers could not afford to give up land to afforestation and wait 30, 40 or 50 years for the trees to mature. In suitable cases we do all we can to encourage afforestation, but I believe that, if the EEC are giving any assistance, they should give it to the State.
Comment on this
In the discussions will the Minister ensure our particular situation—the comparative absence of private forestry in the past and the predominance of small farms—will be fully adverted to by the EEC in their decision? Will he accept that he is, perhaps, a little pessimistic as to the possibilities? Even the smallest farm can with advantage provide shelter belts on a small scale. Apart from that there are vast areas which could be made available for private forestry if the conditions were attractive enough.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Deputy may take it I will do my utmost to have these directive interpreted in the best interests of the prevailing conditions here. The best evidence I can give of that is the fact that I have got Directive 160 altered to apply specifically to prevailing conditions here. I do not want to get into a political argument, but that directive was negotiated by my predecessor.