Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Second TV Channel.
- Second television channel survey cost 21 speeches
The Minister refused to disclose the survey’s cost, citing established practice against revealing the cost of government surveys. He confirmed the Department and RTÉ shared the cost equally, but could not immediately provide a precedent for the nondisclosure.
Tom J. Fitzpatrick, Robert Molloy, Conor Cruise-O'Brien, John Lynch, George Colley
- Second television network costs and completion 11 speeches
The Minister reported £675,000 spent to date, an estimated £4.1 million total capital cost, and completion expected by the end of 1976. He also gave projected annual costs for the proposed RTÉ service at 1975 prices: £2.456 million in 1977, £3.120 million in 1978, and £3.914 million in 1979.
Robert Molloy, Tom J. Fitzpatrick, Conor Cruise-O'Brien, George Colley, John F. O'Connell
- Meeting about rebroadcasting BBC 1 2 speeches
Asked whether he had recently met his English counterpart about rebroadcasting BBC 1 in Ireland, the Minister said he had not.
Tom J. Fitzpatrick, Conor Cruise-O'Brien
(Dublin Central) asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs the cost of carrying out the survey concerning the second television channel.
7.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs the cost of the recent survey carried out into the desired use to be made of the second television transmitter network.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 6 and 7 together.
It would be contrary to established practice to disclose the information requested by the Deputies.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say if the cost of the survey was borne jointly and in equal proportions between the Minister's Department and RTE?
Comment on this
What is the reason for the reluctance on the part of the Minister to disclose the cost to the Department?
Comment on this
Established and general practice in all Government Departments prevalent, as the Deputy ought to be aware, for many years past.
Comment on this
Could the Minister elaborate a little on that statement? He will appreciate that a reference to established and general practice is rather wide and that it would be helpful to the House in understanding the reasoning behind his reply if he were a little more specific in referring to the kind of item which he has in mind as established practice.
Comment on this
I am advised that it is contrary to established practice to disclose the cost of surveys carried out on behalf of Government Departments. The Deputy's experience in this matter is a good deal longer than mine and I am surprised that he is not aware of the practice.
Comment on this
Offhand I cannot recall any precedent for this but, perhaps, the Minister could help us. There may be something in his brief in this regard.
Comment on this
My brief does not disclose anything other than what I have said but if the Deputy wishes to put down another question I shall answer it.
Comment on this
If it is established in general practice, as I am advised, it would be regarded as not necessary.
Comment on this
Would it not be easy for the Minister to indicate to us the previous survey in respect of which it was established practice not to disclose details of the type we are seeking?
Comment on this
I am prepared to furnish that information to the Deputy if he requires it, that is, when I receive it but I have not got it here.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs (a) the total expenditure to date on the provision of a second television transmitter network (b) the total estimated cost of providing a second television transmitter network and (c) when work on the second television transmitter network is expected to be completed.
9.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central) asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs the estimated cost of providing the proposed second television channel.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 8 and 9 together.
The total expenditure to date on the provision of a second television transmitter network is £675,000; the total estimated cost of providing the network is £4.1 million and it is expected that the work will be completed at the end of 1976.
Comment on this
Can the Minister give any indication of the estimated current expenditure in the first year of operation?
Comment on this
If the Deputy puts down a question to that effect, I am sure we can get the information for him.
Comment on this
The Minister's reply appears to have assumed that what was sought was the capital cost but I would suggest that the wording of the question conceivably covers current as well as capital cost—the estimated cost of providing it?
Comment on this
All I can give here is RTE's estimate. I think this is what the Deputy wants. This is the estimate at 1975 prices of what will be the cost of the type of RTE service that is proposed: 1977, £2.456 million, 1978, £3.120 million and 1979, £3.914 million.
10.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central) asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs if he had any recent meeting with his counterpart in England regarding the proposal to rebroadcast BBC 1 in this country.